Categories
Australia

November 6, 1991 – met the new federalism, same as the old federalism

Thirty five years ago, on this day, November 6th, 1991,

A leading Australian conservationist has denounced the “new federalism” initiative as being “old federalism rejigged” and if implemented could jeopardise the future of proposed ecologically sustainable development policies.

Speaking at the National Press Club in Canberra yesterday, the executive director for the Australian Conservation Fund, Phillip Toyne, said that the initiative put forward by the Prime Minister, Bob Hawke, was not “a rethinking of our apportionment of power in government” but mere “rhetoric of change, not change itself”.

Iffland, K. 1991. Toyne: new federalism old federalism rejigged. Canberra Times, 7 November, p.3.

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 355ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that in 1988 the Australian public had been woken up to the threat of carbon dioxide build up, thanks in part to hard work by the CSIRO and various politicians. There had been an intense period of promises of policy making, etc. etc. including the Ecologically Sustainable Development (ESD) process. There had also been loose talk about holding a referendum, so that the federal government would have more power over states around greenhouse issues. This had come to nothing. The ESD, by this stage, was a dead letter, and everybody kind of knew it. Everyone was waiting for former treasurer Paul Keating to make his move to become Prime Minister, and Keating was infamously opposed to climate action.

What I think we can learn from this is that by late 1989 sorry, 1991 unless you were really sucking hard on the hopium pipe, you knew that there were serious problems ahead. 

What happened next Keating did, in fact, topple Hawke, and he did bin all of the ecologically sustainable development stuff. Australia announced an absolutely pitiful National Greenhouse Response Strategy, which they then ignored, and Australian emissions domestically climbed, and their coal exports climbed, and Australian prime ministers like Keating and Howard and Rudd do belong at The Hague, (it would be a relatively crowded dock).

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 6, 1961 – “Air Over Cities” pollution conference begins 

November 6, 1988 – Australian cartoonist nails response to #climate change

November 6, 1989 – Noordwijk conference – “alright, we will keep talking”

November 6, 1990 – Second World Climate Conference underway

November 6, 2001 – Howard plays the jobs-card vs Kyoto in Hunter Valley

November 6, 2009 – Kevin Rudd playing politics with the climate

November 6, 2011 – Keystone…

Categories
United Kingdom

November 6, 1958 – Gordon Manley on sea level rise would “make quite a mess of most of our sea ports”

Sixty eight years ago, on this day, November 6th, 1958,

By the year 2000 it may be possible to forecast good or bad summers many years ahead, an expert in climatology, Professor Gordon Manley, said in Coventry last night.

…

“There was no doubt that the ice in the polar regions was melting, resulting in an increase in sea level, he said… “If the sea level is rising to a much greater level than we think it would make quite a mess of most of our sea ports..”

Anon. 1958. Climate key explained in Coventry. Coventry Evening Telegraph, November 7, p.22

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 313ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that in 1938 Guy Callender had given a presentation at the Royal Meteorological Society about carbon dioxide build up and the heating of the planet. He received a lukewarm reception. However, one person who was on board was Gordon Manley, and Manley had been quoted in 1954 or ‘55 , as saying that in 30 years time we’d be growing grapes and have orange trees in the south of England.

The specific context was that it has basically been agreed by scientists studying within the International Geophysical Year, they’ve released an interim report in June that has said the world is one big greenhouse. And so here Manley is saying that seaports may be wiped out by rising sea level rise.

And it’s important to remember that whether you believed in carbon dioxide build up or not, there was enough evidence to convince everyone that the earth was warming up for whatever reason, and that ice would melt. . .

What I think we can learn from this is that the warnings were there.

What happened next – we kept emitting carbon dioxide in enormous quantities. The Fafocene is here.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 6, 1961 – “Air Over Cities” pollution conference begins 

November 6, 1988 – Australian cartoonist nails response to #climate change

November 6, 1989 – Noordwijk conference – “alright, we will keep talking”

November 6, 1990 – Second World Climate Conference underway

November 6, 2001 – Howard plays the jobs-card vs Kyoto in Hunter Valley

November 6, 2009 – Kevin Rudd playing politics with the climate

November 6, 2011 – Keystone…

Categories
CO2 Newsletter CO2 Newsletter commentary

CO2 Newsletter Vol. 1, no. 4 – “The future is a flitting songbird; just because you see it clearly once doesn’t mean it’ll be in your line of sight forever.”

Professor Cyrus Mody (bio below) ponders the CO2 Newsletter, its place in history and how we think about the past, the present the future in a commentary on CO2 Newsletter, v. 3, n. 4 (May-June, 1982)

Professor Cyrus Mody

Other commentaries in this series have – rightly – marveled at William Barbat’s prescience in raising the alarm about climate change in the years around 1980. And the May-June, 1982 edition doesn’t disappoint in that respect. For example, an abstract by Karl W. Butzer on “Socio-economic implications … for CO2-induced climate change” concludes that “the pending crisis of the 21st century” [i.e., our present!] would take three forms:

  1. A substantial reduction of the world food supply, at a time of maximum demographic pressures upon global resources and shrinking energy reserves;
  2. Selective decline of productivity among the major economic and food-producing nations, implying a fundamental readjustment between developed and developing world regions; and
  3. Differential impacts within undersupplied nations of special complexity, as resources become inadequate to maintain controlled ecosystems, raising the probability of severe internal disruptions and confrontations within existing socioeconomic subsystems.

Some of those scenarios are still “pending” but the outlines of that forecast still ring eerily true.

Similarly, elsewhere Barbat quotes William C. Clark’s Carbon Dioxide Review: 1982. If the Lovinses soft path or the French nuclear path become universal, things will be okay; but, Clark says, “if, on the other hand, the world returns to high energy growth rates that characterized the third quarter of the present century, and fuels this growth with coal, then many of us now working on the CO2 question could see a 600 ppm world within our lifetime.” For the most part, the world did reject the Lovinses and nuclear power, and fossil fuel use did rebound, with coal remaining a dominant primary fuel across much of the world. The prediction of 600 ppm by, say, 2050 is a bit beyond the outer edge of IPCC predictions, but not by much (and the IPCC’s outer edge might well be an underestimate). So, once again, Barbat’s reporting was sound and if people had followed his lead the climatic drivers of today’s polycrisis would be much less pressing.

Yet we have to remember that the CO2 Newsletter is an historical source, and thus our admiration for Barbat should be spiced with source criticism. He wasn’t infallible, and the common ground with his admirers today was perhaps less than they might think. Other commentators have noted, for example, that his preferred form of climate action was “the French nuclear strategy” rather than “the Lovinses view of the global future;” as he put it in this issue, “the only non-fossil energy alternative presently feasible on a grand scale [is] nuclear fission.” Barbat’s contempt for what he called “the self-proclaimed environmental protection movement” also shines through here and in other editions of the newsletter.

Most notably – at least to an historian of science such as myself – in this edition Barbat reveals himself to be a continental drift skeptic. Now, continental drift and climate change do have a complicated relationship. For one thing, the influential historian of climate denialism, Naomi Oreskes, is also the world’s leading historian of continental drift; for her, both are examples of sciences where early investigators had good arguments and evidence but were ignored or overridden by conservative peers. Conversely, for climate denialists, obstructionists, and fellow travelers1 the lesson of continental drift is that supposed free-thinkers should be listened to, because they could turn out to be the next Alfred Wegener (or Darwin, Galileo, etc.).

Yet Barbat offers an unusual third option: that climate scientists should be listened to precisely because they have the hard facts – and the intuitive plausibility – that continental drift is missing!

The notion of actively drifting continents offers a contrasting study with the CO2-greenhouse theory in regard to disciplined scientific rigorousness and popularity. The greenhouse effect of atmospheric CO2 is solidly founded on thermodynamic investigations which have been checked and rechecked over and over again to produce a rather consistent range of appraisals (consensus)… In contrast, scientific disciplinarians are able to show that active continental drift is fatally flawed on both a physical and chemical basis. No proposed driving mechanisms can begin to match the forces that would be needed to move ponderous continental masses apart on highly viscous magma.

And yet, Barbat bemoans, “the notion of active drift was accorded credibility in virtually all school texts to produce popularity before a truly disciplined case was made, and large research enterprises have a vested interest in perpetuating the funding and publishing of one-sided studies” – i.e., much the same criticism that denialists make about climate science!

Thus, Barbat was something of a contrarian. It therefore wouldn’t have been surprising if he had later followed other contrarians – such as Freeman Dyson – in moving from climate awareness toward climate denial, especially given Barbat’s proximity to the oil industry, fondness for nuclear power, and antipathy toward environmentalists (all common traits of later eco-modernists and other hulpmollen). We have to evaluate his prescience circa 1980 as a product of its time from which we can’t infer his later evolution. The future is a flitting songbird; just because you see it clearly once doesn’t mean it’ll be in your line of sight forever.

What the CO2 Newsletter does tell us, though, is that climate awareness was the contrarian position circa 1980, at least for people in Barbat’s milieu. As he complained,

The CO2 problem suffers from a lack of popularity. No rock concerts have decried the CO2 buildup, and no bumper stickers advocating a halt to the CO2 buildup have appeared on fossil-fueled autos. Popular scientific magazines that advertise expensive non-utilitarian autos2 seem unusually silent on the CO2-greenhouse problem.

His aim for the newsletter, therefore, was “to fill the vacuum left by a noticeable de-emphasis of the entire CO2 problem in more widely read publications.” Notably, this edition of the newsletter opens with an open correspondence between Barbat and John Haun, president of the American Geological Institute and thus a staunch representative of the establishment. For Haun, Barbat’s “mental attitude [presents] a real danger in emphasizing all the bits and pieces of evidence that tend to support your hypothesis and denigrating or giving short shrift to the opposing evidence.” Barbat’s response is revealing: “To offset what may be overblown fears of ours, we have been directly urging editors of widely-read periodicals to give the CO2 problem more extensive coverage [and] more comprehensive studies on all aspects of the CO2 problem.”

And it’s on that score that I think we should give Barbat credit, rather than for his prescience alone. Much has been made in recent years of what various people and oil companies knew (or #Knew) about climate change circa 1980. But “knowing” is a fleeting act, not a permanent condition, especially for an organization like an oil firm. What’s important is what people and entities do at the moment that they know. Barbat knew – and he acted on that knowledge by spreading knowledge of climate change as widely as he could. And it’s thanks to lonely and courageous voices like his that denial became the rightly stigmatized position that it is today.

Footnotes

1 I propose the Dutch neologism hulpmol for someone who aids denialists but can’t be labeled one themselves. The word comes from the fanbase of the reality show Wie is de mol?, in which a “mole” sabotages their peers. A hulpmol is someone who wittingly or unwittingly assists the mole’s efforts and prevents their unmasking.

2 Elsewhere, it’s clear that he means fuel-efficient vehicles, which he says only encourage environmentalists to drive in ways that actually increase carbon emissions.

Bio

Cyrus Mody is Professor of the History of Science, Technology, and Innovation at Maastricht University and author of three monographs with MIT Press, most recently The Squares: US Physical and Engineering Scientists in the Long 1970s. He was PI of the Dutch Research Council-funded  Managing Scarcity project (VI.C.191.067), 2020-2026.

Categories
United Kingdom

November 5, 1989 – “UK hinders move to halt global warming”

Thirty seven years ago, on this day, November 5th, 1989,

UK hinders moves to halt global warming

Geoffrey Lean and Jan Sinclair in the Observer

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 353ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that Margaret Thatcher had been briefed repeatedly on carbon dioxide build up, for example, 1979 and 1984 and had persistently and consistently said, I’m not interested, you want me to worry about the weather. 

The specific context was that in the second half of 1988 Crispin Tickell finally convinced her it was a serious issue, and she could see the writing on the wall, and she performed one of her many turns, because the lady was indeed for turning. She gave a speech in September 1988 which really kick-started the whole climate issue, which was already underway – for example, the conference in Toronto. Thatcher was doing what politicians do, getting ahead of an issue that was already starting anyway. In May of 1989 President Bush was forced to change his tune and talk about, yes, the need for an actual carbon treaty. Here we see a few months later, the Energy Minister  Baroness INSERT NAME had kiboshed the Toronto target.

What I think we can learn from this is that the UK is very good at talking the talk of justice, equality, fairness, etc. Slightly less good at walking the walk.

What happened next. The UK didn’t even put climate change on the literal agenda when it hosted the G7 in 1991 because this was going to offend President Bush. They are very much the “junior partner”, and they were the ones who negotiated the surrender of the pro targets and timetables people in 1992 ahead of the Earth Summit.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

60 years ago today, the first US government report to warn about climate change was published.

November 5, 1969 – House of Lords question about the greenhouse effect

November 5, 1992 – Jeremy Leggett calls Australian petrol price cuts “insane”

November 5, 1997 – Global Climate Coalition co-ordinates an anti-Kyoto conference

November 5, 2008 – Queen asks the key question

November 5, 2014 – Vince Cable and the Energy Trilemma

Categories
CO2 Newsletter

C02 Newsletter May 1982 – “1981 sets modern heat record”

The sixteenth edition of the CO2 Newsletter, published bi-monthly by American geologist William N. Barbat between 1979 and 1982 is live. You can download a pdf, or read the html version here.

The eight page issue has a front page story on 1981 as the hottest year… oh, such innocent times.

There isn’t, for once, an editorial, but instead some interesting correspondence. There’s the usual “excerpts from recent reports” and then a closing short article “Potential sources of capital to halt the CO2 buildup”.

Barbat’s work, his prescience, deserve our attention and respect.

Categories
Fossil fuels

November 4, 2016 – “Oil chiefs try to boost green credentials with new investment fund.”

Ten years ago, on this day, November 4th, 2016,

Some of the world’s biggest oil companies including Shell and BP are preparing to announce a new green energy investment fund as they seek to improve their environmental reputation. Chief executives Ben van Beurden and Bob Dudley, along with the heads of Saudi Aramco, Repsol, Eni, Statoil and Total, are due to unveil details of the fund at an event in London on Friday [4th November] to coincide with the Paris climate agreement coming into force. 

Gosden, E. (2016) Oil chiefs try to boost green credentials with new investment fund. The Telegraph, November 2.

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 405ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was oil companies had known they faced reputational and potential legislative threats for decades. They had fought successfully against the latter via outfits like the Global Climate Coalition (1989-2002).

The specific context was Paris had happened the year before and everyone was still in the pretend phase.

What I think we can learn from this – people like to pretend. You get a better sort of canapes at ‘let’s all pretend capitalism is sustainable’ events.

What happened next capitalism continued to be unsustainable. Oh well.

xxx

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 4, 1959 – Edward Teller tells it like it is

November 4, 1988 – no quick fix on climate, warns Australian Environment Minister

November 4, 1991 – UK Government launches first of many blame-shifting publicity campaigns on #climate

November 4, 1999 – Australians have highest per capita emissions

November 4, 2006 – Australians “Walk against Warming”

Categories
Australia

November 3, 1997- innovative energy solutions, oh my…

Twenty nine years ago, on this day, November 3rd, 1997,

Greenhouse & innovative energy solutions into the 21st Century : Monday, 3 November 1997 – Sydney / presented by the Greenhouse Challenge Office in association with the Electricity Supply Association of Australia Limited and The Australian Gas Association.

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 365ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that from 1950s it had been obvious that fossil fuel usage for energy and electricity generation, whether that was heat, power, cars, was going to have significant ecological and social consequences, and therefore other energy sources might be the way forward, be that nuclear or renewables, or whatever.

The specific context was that from the late 1980s there had been talk of a global climate treaty, which would involve rich nations cutting their emissions first, that had been partially successfully resisted. But there was the Kyoto conference coming up in a month’s time, and so anticipating that there would be some agreement by industrial nations, the idea of “innovative energy solutions” was more likely to catch headlines.

What I think we can learn from this is that you should never see events and claims in isolation from the historical events they are in; that’s a banality, but mostly what I do is banalities.

What happened next we did eventually, 20 years later, start seeing some of these innovative energy solutions, not actually that innovative. But anyway, have they helped bend the emissions curve down? No, not particularly. Will they? Possibly. Will that do much of anything about the atmospheric concentrations of carbon dioxide? No, for that, you would need all sorts of magical “draw down” technologies, which don’t exist, and unless we repeal some laws, won’t exist. “Repeal some laws?” you say. “Well, that sounds doable.” Yes, but those are laws of physics…

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 3, 1916 -measurement of ice flow shows climate change

November 3, 1988 – priorities revealed via adverts

November 3, 1990 – more smears about the IPCC, in the Financial Times 

November 3, 1990 – money for independent climate scientists? Yeah, nah

November 3, 2000 – Australian denialists get American scientist to testify about Kyoto Protocol, smear IPCC

November 3, 2007 – Second Rising Tide Australia boat blockade

Categories
Australia Carbon Pricing

November 2, 1998 – Emissions trading within a year, oh yes.

Twenty eight years ago, on this day, November 2nd, 1998,

SYDNEY (Dow Jones)–The Sydney Futures Exchange said Monday it aims to have a gas emissions trading system operational within 12 months.

This follows a meeting last Monday held between Australia’s New South Wales state government, energy industry representatives and financial market participants to discuss forming a market for trading greenhouse gas emissions.

A working group will soon be established to examine the most appropriate structure for such a scheme, the SFE said. “Any testing of an emissions trading scheme will be as broad as possible and conducted in real time,” the exchange added. The trading scheme will also meet national and international policy on greenhouse emissions, the SFE said.

The development of an international emissions market will be discussed at the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change in Buenos Aires, running from Nov. 2 to 13, the SFE said. The SFE said it will be represented at the convention.

At the Dec. 1997 U.N. climate change convention in Kyoto, Japan, a number of developed countries made binding targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Australia has committed to limit emissions to 108% of 1990 levels. Greenhouse emissions trading is seen as increasing the incentive to meet greenhouse gas emission targets.

1998 – Australia’s SFE Aims To Trade Gas Emissions Within A Year

Monday 2 November 1998

Dow Jones International News

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 382ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that one of the obvious actions you would take to reduce carbon dioxide emissions is to put a tax on carbon, and this would incentivize both energy efficiency and the search for new forms of energy generation, especially wind and solar. Entirely logical, but of course that would interfere with the present and especially future profits of people, companies with enormous power, and so it will surprise no one to say that carbon tax proposals had been defeated, and carbon emissions proposals had had a similarly rocky road.

The specific context was that the climate issue had burst onto the scene again. In mid late 2006 for a variety of reasons in Australia, those reasons included the millennium drought, which was seemingly endless. 

What I think we can learn from this here is that when an issue has burst back onto the scene people overestimate how quickly a policy solution will be implemented, even if it’s merely legislation, let alone, god forbid, technology. 

What happened next There was a five year bloodbath around emissions trading. I don’t think there’s any other word for it. Finally, in July of 2012 an emissions trading scheme began, only to be swiftly abolished by the next (Liberal) government.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 2, 1957 – “Our Coal Fires are melting the poles” Birmingham Post

November 2, 1965  – The Met Office starts twice daily weather forecasts

November 2, 1966 – a pivotal paper is submitted

November 2, 1972 – “Eco-pornography … Advertising owns Ecology”…

November 2, 1994 – Greenpeace vs climate risk for corporates…

November 2, 2006 – throwing shade at the Great Barrier Reef

November 2, 2006 – “RIP C02” says New Scientist

November 2, 2009 – , Australian opposition leader Malcolm Turnbull seals own doom by not bending knee to shock jock

Categories
Australia

November 1, 2001- John Howard with more bullshit

Twenty five years ago, on this day, November 1st, 2001,

One billion dollars of money already allocated in this year’s Budget for a restructured Natural Heritage Trust formed the centrepiece of the Coalition’s environment policy, announced yesterday.

Launching the policy on the mist-shrouded banks of the upper Yarra, in the marginal Coalition seat of McEwen, the Prime Minister said Australia “had punched above its weight” on international environmental issues.

But the policy was immediately denounced by green groups as the worst environmental policy since the 1970s.

The Australian Conservation Foundation executive director, Don Henry, said that while the Government was investing money in tree planting it would fail on key issues such as salinity and greenhouse by not committing on legislation on land clearing and ratifying the Kyoto Protocol.

2001 Banham, C. 2001. Howls Of Anger As PM Paints Himself Green. Sydney Morning Herald, 2 November, p.8.

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 371ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that Australian political elites had briefly (1988 to 1990) thought about doing the right thing and being a responsible global player, and had quickly realised this would involve them picking fights with very powerful vested interests, and perhaps interfere with their post-career sinecures, so they chose the other side. 

The specific context was that John Howard had by this stage already won three elections, 1996-1998 and the November 2001 Federal election was nine days away, so of course he was spouting absolute bullshit. 

What I think we can learn from this is that if you have self-confidence and the media on your side, because your rich mates approve of what you’re doing, since it’s making them even richer, you can get away with any amount of crap, especially if the electorate is poorly educated, poorly informed, subject to propaganda, etc. 

What happened next Howard continued to get away with anti-climate action until late 2006 when the tide finally turned and he was then booted out at the next election. 

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 1, 1953 – Australia strikes oil

November 1, 1959 – M1 motorway section opened

November 1, 1965 – “Fortune” magazine covers carbon dioxide build-up

November 1, 1968 – Ida Hoos on carbon dioxide build-up

 November 1, 1969 – “Carbon dioxide affects global ecology”

November 1, 1970 – Ayn Rand fulminates incorrectly, for the first time ever

November 1, 1974 – UK civil servants writing to each other on “Climatology”

November 1, 1975 – Stephen Schneider tries to clear up the “Carbon Dioxide Climate Confusion.”

November 1988 – Australian Mining Journal says C02 is a Good Thing

November 1, 1989 – Senior Australian politician talks on “Industry and Environment”

November 1, 1989 – “Greenhouse Action Australia” launches…

November 1, 2004 – Brilliant “Balance as Bias” article published

Categories
United Kingdom

October 31, 1992- A Schumacher lecture – “Environmental Literacy: Education as if the Earth Mattered”

Thirty four years ago, on this day, October 31st, 1992,

Environmental Literacy: Education as if the Earth Mattered

By David W. Orr https://centerforneweconomics.org/publications/environmental-literacy-education-as-if-the-earth-mattered/

Yet there are better reasons to rethink education that have to do with issues of human survival, which will dominate the world of the twenty-first century. The generation now being educated will have to do what we, the present generation, have been unable or unwilling to do: stabilize a world population that is growing at the rate of a quarter of a million each day; stabilize and then reduce the emission of greenhouse gases, which threaten to change the climate—perhaps disastrously; protect biological diversity, now declining at an estimated rate of one hundred to two hundred species per day; reverse the destruction of rainforests (both tropical and temperate), now being lost at the rate of one hundred and sixteen square miles or more each day; and conserve soils, now being eroded at the rate of sixty-five million tons per day. Those who follow us must learn how to use energy and materials with great efficiency. They must learn how to utilize solar energy in all its forms. They must rebuild the economy in order to eliminate waste and pollution. They must learn how to manage renewable resources for the long term. They must begin the great work of repairing, as much as possible, the damage done to the earth in the past two hundred years of industrialization. And they must do all of this while addressing worsening social and racial inequities. No generation has ever faced a more daunting agenda.

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 356ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was is that whenever there is an intractable political issue that is going result in deadlock and bloodshed and so forth, you’ll always find some liberals slapping the word “literacy” after whatever it is, because information deficit model has held a role with their touching faith in humanity and the adequate ability, if not perfectibility, of man. And of course banging on about information deficit models, or within that scope allows you to avoid tricky questions about power and privilege. It also gives you a privileged position of being the lecturer, the hector who knows things that other people need to know. 

The specific context was the UN climate treaty had been signed and would – at some point in the coming years – be ratified by enough nations to become lore. Sorry law.

What I think we can learn from is there’s always people like that willing to jump here. If the problem is lack of knowledge, necessarily, it gives them status, it gives them comfort, gives them money.What happened next. Your friendly neighbourhood liberals kept banging on about literacy as the first (and often foremost and final) action. And other people kept being somewhat less impressed.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

October 31, 1994 – Four Corners reports on Greenhouse Mafia activity

October 31, 2004 – QE2 lobbied Blair on climate, reports Observer

October 31, 2006 – Stern Review “pure speculation” according to John Howard

October 31, 2018 – Extinction Rebellion makes its declaration of rebellion