Categories
CO2 Newsletter

CO2 Newsletter Vol. 3, no.5 –

The penultimate Newsletter of the extraordinary “CO2 Newsletter” is now live! You can download it as a pdf or word doc, or read the full text here.

It was the brainchild of an American geologist, William Barbat, who started it in 1979. There were 18 astonishing issues, packed with facts, perspectives and a now-horrifying prescience.

This issue has a front page story on the instability of the West Antarctic Icesheet

In his editorial, with unquenched optimism, Barbat writes

“In our estimation, only a few well-placed articles of such enlightenment in the popular press would be needed to bring this matter squarely into the public forum in a timely fashion.”

There are the usual excerpts from recent reports, and a banger of a closing article, by Barbat, “On quantification of risk” which begins thus –

Public debates on the risks and acceptability of nuclear energy bear directly on the speed at which nuclear energy might supplant fossil energy to halt the CO2 buildup. An article by Peter G. Groer in Summer 1982 Institute for Energy Analysis Newsletter provides a graphic scientific foundation for estimating chance and analyzing risk that might successfully end arguments through rational quantification.

Categories
United States of America

 November 17, 1961 – The Midnight Sun…

Sixty five years ago, on this day, November 17th, 1961,

Nov 17 1961 – “The Midnight Sun” is episode 75 of the American television anthology series The Twilight Zone, first shown in November, 1961.

Opening narration

The word that Mrs. Bronson is unable to put into the hot, still, sodden air is ‘doomed,’ because the people you’ve just seen have been handed a death sentence. One month ago, the Earth suddenly changed its elliptical orbit and in doing so began to follow a path which gradually, moment by moment, day by day, took it closer to the Sun. And all of man’s little devices to stir up the air are now no longer luxuries—they happen to be pitiful and panicky keys to survival. The time is five minutes to twelve, midnight. There is no more darkness. The place is New York City and this is the eve of the end, because even at midnight it’s high noon, the hottest day in history, and you’re about to spend it in the Twilight Zone. Whether explicitly nuclear or otherwise, the apocalypse was never far away [in the Twilight Zone]. “The Midnight Sun” was telecast on the day the U.S. consolidated its drive for “push-button warfare” with the first successful launching of a Minuteman missile from an underground silo. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Midnight_Sun_(The_Twilight_Zone)

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 317ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that The Twilight Zone was an enormously successful TV show. Rod Serling had had a tough time of it in World War Two in the Philippines, and it somewhat fucked him up, but he had a pretty good imagination, and the golden age of sci-fi was underway. Questions about the planets and what would happen to Earth “if dot dot dot” were live.

The specific context was humans were blowing shit up (A-bombs, H-bombs) all over the place, and JFK had called at the UN General Assembly for agreements around weather modification etc.

What I think we can learn from this is that all sorts of questions around what it means to be human and how fragile the planet is were pretty well understood. This was, after all, the time of potential thermonuclear war at any given minute. The Berlin Wall had gone up and Khrushchev thought that he could push Kennedy around, and Kennedy needed to prove that he couldn’t be pushed around, especially after the Bay of Pigs debacle. It was all quite dick-swing-y.

What happened next Twilight Zone kept pumping out the good stuff, I’m told the 1980s reboot wasn’t quite so good. I saw a few episodes, it was fine, but maybe my standards were lower.

xxx

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 17, 1869 – Suez Canal opens

 November 17, 1961 – we enter the Twilight Zone

November 17, 1968 -The Observer covers carbon dioxide pollution…

November 17, 1968 – UK national newspaper flags carbon dioxide danger…

November 17, 1975 – “Living with Climatic Change” conference begins in Toronto

November 17, 1978 – British Wind Energy Association launches

November 17, 1980 – International meeting about carbon dioxide build up.

November 17, 1994 – “When consumption is no longer sustainable”…

November 17,  2009 – Manchester CIty Council signs off on a climate action plan

November 17,  2009 – “Climategate” hack

November 17, 2018 – XR occupy five bridges in London

November 17, 2023 – two degrees warmer, for the first time…

November 17 – World Vasectomy Day

Categories
United States of America

November 16, 1990 – Bush signs an Act

Thirty six years ago, on this day, November 16th, 1990,

 George Bush the 1st signed the “U.S. Global Change Research Act of 1990:”

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 354ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that George H. W. Bush had won the 1988 election, and among his promises was that he would use the White House effect to deal with the greenhouse effect.

Once he had power, he changed his tune – what a surprise. He had to be sort of forced into seeing the need for a global treaty: his chief of staff, John Sununu, who’s still alive, was instrumental in stopping the US rather having anything approaching a sane position 

The specific context was that even within this there was still a wing of the Republican party that believed in, you know, “environment stuff,” Russell Train, William Reilly, etc. 

What I think we can learn from this is there’s always, if you choose to look for them, signs of “hope”. I would call those false, false hope, a fundamental misunderstanding of what is going on. 

What happened next Bush successfully stopped there being targets and timetables in the climate treaty, and that has doomed us all. 

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 16, 1982 – development aid and the greenhouse effect…

 November 16, 1994 – Industry lobbyists trot out “sky will fall” argument against emissions cuts. Again. Of course. As ever.

November 16, 1995 – another skirmish in the IPCC war

November 16, 2009 – who is going to PAY for CCS? Well, you, obvs.

November 16, 2021 – Chancellor cuddles up to oil bosses, of course.

Categories
El Nino

END Times 9, November 15

END Times 9 as a pdf and as a word document

DO YOU SEA WHAT I SEA?

“Satellite measurements show that the current El Niño resembles the 1997–98 event, with warm water stretching across the equatorial Pacific to South America. But that oceanic resemblance does not guarantee the same weather during winter 2026–27, as the outcome also depends on how the atmosphere responds.”

Anon, 2026. NASA Warns a Monster El Niño Could Surpass the Historic 1997 Event. SciTechDaily, November 11

Quote of the week

“The effects of these El Niños are not benign,” said Cullen Hendrix, a senior fellow at the Peterson Institute for International Economics who has estimated that this event could cost the global economy more than $7 trillion over the next five years. “We’re talking about a phenomenon that has systemic impacts that can adversely affect populations all across the globe.” 

Lu, C. 2026. The Global Economy Braces for Yet Another Blow. Foreign Policy, November 10.

Welcome to the 9th weekly issue of the El Niño Digest Times  (END Times – geddit?). The why should be self-explanatory, but here’s a FAQ  just in case. We are still just about in the first of the three phases of El Niño but not for long… 

There are a lot of good El Niño explainers out there –  this one, by Al Jazeera is really good and I will link to it at the top of every digest until someone suggests a better one (ideally with the url written on a £50 note).


Editorial

There’s a scene in Monty Python and the Holy Grail where one of the characters John Cleese plays tells two idiots what to do (stay and guard the prisoner) and they are too dumb to follow orders. Then they look out the window (well, slit) and see someone running towards them with bad intent. They look again and again, and he’s still at the same point, running but not getting closer.

And then, in an eye blink, in the time it takes a fist to turn into an open palm, he’s there, slaughtering them.

That’s what (to me) this particular bit of the beginning of phase two, looks like. You know it’s coming – you can see it running towards you – but it doesn’t seem to be getting any closer. This is surely entirely to do with where I live, in a sleepy part of England.  Anyway, here we are.

Meanwhile, I continue to indulge in unhelpful and reductive sweeping generalisations about the entirety of our species.  But also, goddamn Hairless Murder Apes…

The three phases of El Niño 

  1. The Antici…pation

From early this year until … (looks at watch)… about now. Scientists saying they’ve double-checked and triple-checked and they’re as sure as they can be. Disaster management folks pleading for money and decent plans. Politicians telling us to stock up, or declaring States of Emergency in advance, with an eye on their 2028 Presidential run… Journalists writing SEO-ed disaster porn speculations. Everyone holding their breath, putting their fingers in their ears to not hear the Doomers gloating “I told you so.”

  1. “Then someone yelled out ‘Contact!’”

The rolling roiling disasters, especially salient when (rich) White People in Peril can be filmed.  The shark in the shopping mall meme resurfaces. The re-insurers point to their fine print, and some insurers go belly-up. The rich libertarians squeal for state bail-outs. Food prices through the roof. Hard-to-replace infrastructure washed away.

  1. Back to the perfect paradise

The wreckage is quietly swept away, the global machine reboots, and the important (rich white) people continue their merry way. The End.  (Actual outcomes may vary; always read the label).

QUOTES OF THE WEEK

“El Nino is a massive threat to the food security of millions who are already vulnerable,” Carl Skau, WFP’s acting executive director. (cited in Ali and Haddad, 2026, Sept 15). 


“El Nino is being supersized before our eyes…. The science leaves no room for doubt: the planet is in uncharted waters, and those waters are heat

ing up.”  

UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said in a WMO statement.


 “A few inches of extra ocean may not sound like much, but coastal flooding is a game of margins stacked on margins. The wave itself will not flood anything on its own — this is not a tsunami, and there will be no moment when it ‘hits.’ Instead, it quietly raises the baseline the tides ride on top of for weeks or months at a time,”

Macaday, S. 2026. El Niño-born ‘Kelvin waves’ are sneaking towards California. What to know. Sacramento Bee, September 14

https://www.sacbee.com/news/weather-news/article317211661.html


“We can’t just assume that this El Niño is going to be the same as the last because there are so many challenges that have been stacking on top of each other.” 

“We have come to a stage where climate change is putting so much pressure on us – on our existing, already crumbling or structurally unsound, systems…. Nature will force us to have a reckoning.”

 Elyssa Kaur Ludher, a climate and food security expert based in Singapore.

Holmes et a.l, 2026. ‘Forcing a reckoning’: How Asia is preparing for a ‘supersized’ El Niño. The Guardian, September 18

‘Forcing a reckoning’: How Asia is preparing for a ‘supersized’ El Niño | El Niño southern oscillation | The Guardian 


“I have never seen an El Niño signal this intense in our forecasts. A typical El Niño leads to an equatorial Pacific sea-surface temperature rise of between 1-2 degrees, with 2C being a really big event….This implies that if the forecast is accurate – and other forecast systems show similar extreme values – then 2026 will far exceed our recent experience of El Niño and its worldwide climate influences.”

  Professor Adam Scaife, head of long range forecasting at the Met Office  (August 2026)


Think Global Health: What’s your reaction to the El Niño news, and what impact could extreme weather have on global food insecurity?

Sam Vigersky: I’m hesitant to say that this couldn’t come at a worse time—because something worse can always happen—but it’s arriving at a moment when the international humanitarian system has no shock absorbers left. The funding cuts ongoing since 2022 became truly catastrophic in 2025 after the Trump administration leveled the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID).

Krugman, A. 2026. A Food Security Expert on the Record-Breaking El Niño. Think Health Global, September 18

https://www.thinkglobalhealth.org/article/a-food-security-expert-on-the-record-breaking-el-nino


 “Historical precedent can no longer serve as a reliable guide for ENSO teleconnections, as anthropogenic warming patterns intensify.” 

NCAR senior scientist Clara Deser 

Newsby article Sept 20 2026


“This event is a huge redistribution of energy in the climate system and is dangerous because it is unfolding on top of a much warmer, human-influenced climate system. So, in many places around the world we will see never-before-experienced heat extremes, with all their consequences on health, food security and water stress. El Niño comes and goes, but as long as we continue to burn fossil fuels it occurs on an increasingly hotter baseline, making it much more difficult for communities to deal with the consequences.” 

Prof Friederike Otto, at Imperial College London, quoted in Carrington, D. 2026, Sept 21

ROUND THE WORLD

Good overview!

El Nino Watch: The impacts around the world this week | ABS-CBN News 

World

El Nino could intensify heat-related illnesses, disease outbreaks and air pollution into 2027, World Meteorological Organization (WMO) Secretary-General Celeste Saulo warned Monday.

Speaking at a COP31 news briefing in Antalya, Saulo said above-average temperatures could trigger health threats extending beyond direct exposure to extreme heat.

“We are speaking also about dengue outbreaks, malaria outbreaks,” she said, explaining that the risks would vary depending on regional rainfall patterns.

“If we expect a hot and dry season, you will have wildfires. With wildfires, you will have poor air quality,” she said.

Necva Tastan Sevinc  2026 El Nino threatens to worsen disease outbreaks, heat risks into 2027: WMO chief AA, November 9

PACIFIC

During the three strongest El Niño events since 1997–1998, the land carbon sink weakened by as much as 50%. Elevated temperatures and water stress suppressed photosynthesis, reducing the amount of carbon absorbed by vegetation. Meanwhile, increased ecosystem respiration and wildfire activity released additional carbon back into the atmosphere.

Using the 2026 El Niño as a testbed, researchers, supported by the European Space Agency’s (ESA’s), Climate Change Initiative, have developed an initial framework to identify and quantify carbon-cycle risk hotspots before the full impacts unfold.

Anon, 2026. Predicting El Nino’s impact on carbon sinks. ESA, November 10 


A monster is growing in the Pacific — not the kraken, but something far scarier and deadlier. El Niño is a natural phenomenon in which a band of warm water forms every three to five years off the coast of South America. It raises ocean water temperatures by just a few extra degrees for typically nine to 12 months and ends up injecting an extraordinary amount of energy into the sky. It’s already the strongest El Niño on record, and it might not even peak for about another month or two.

“Those are actually really big changes for the ocean,” Art Miller, a climate scientist at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, told Grist in September. “The ocean has a lot of heat content — 1,000 times more ability to hold heat than the atmosphere — so slight changes in the ocean surface temperatures can actually do a lot for the atmosphere.”

Austin Corona and Leia Larsen  2026. A monstrous El Niño has arrived. Here’s what it means for where you live. | Grist November 9

ASIA

Indonesia’s fiercest fires in at least a decade were amplified by an “El Niño that turned off the taps” and “fossil fuels that turned up the heat”, scientists have revealed.

Along with the conversion of forests to plantations, this created the conditions for blazes that have burned almost 3m hectares (7.4m acres) – 19 times the size of Greater London – this year, and 

cast a choking haze across much of south-east Asia.

An international team of World Weather Attribution scientists analysed the different elements of this triple whammy in Java, Kalimantan and Sumatra to assess how each affected the peak fire season from August to October.

Watts, J. 2026. ‘El Niño turned off the taps’: factors behind Indonesia’s wildfires revealed | Indonesia | The Guardian November 13


AFRICA

The current El Niño event could be unprecedented in strength – off the monitoring charts that have been used for the past four decades – and will peak towards the end of 2026. Eastern Africa in particular is facing heightened humanitarian risks as El Niño conditions. Present since June 2026, these risks are expected to strengthen into a potentially very strong event and persist through late 2026 and early 2027

Public Health Situation Analysis (PHSA) – Impact of El Niño in the Africa Region


Floods disproportionately affect informal settlements in Nairobi, especially those near rivers, like Kibera and Mathare.

In most of these settlements, houses sit just a few metres from rivers. Some people, including Shikoli, live on the slopes of the river itself due to the constant expansion of the settlements. When flash floods occur, these houses are swept away, endangering the lives of their occupants.

Nairobi’s drainage system has not been upgraded to deal with the rapid growth in the population and infrastructure over the decades

“The existing drainage system was developed 30 years ago to cater for a population of about 2.5 million residents but we’re dealing with about seven million in the daytime and 5.5 million night-time,” Simiyu says.

Mukhwana, T. 2026. ‘It can kill us’: Kenyans fear impact of El Niño with floods predicted. BBC November 11


The economy of Nyanga, in Zimbabwe’s eastern highlands, mostly runs on tourism, but those in the rural areas survive on farming. But climate change is threatening their livelihoods. 

In September, the World Meteorological Organization announced that the El Nino climate pattern is strengthening rapidly in the Pacific Ocean, raising the prospect of months of extreme heat, floods and drought around the globe. Forecasters predict it will peak around late 2026 and continue until at least February next year.

Matiashe, F-S. 2026. Southern African farmers prepare for powerful El Nino with agroecology. RFI, November 8


NORTH AMERICA

“Mike Couffer, a semiretired biologist from Newport Beach, has been scuba diving nearly every day to see the mohawk-style fins of star-studded grouper, tiny iridescent orange creolefish, three-banded butterflyfish, and other exotic fish hardly ever seen in this area. “It’s just nuts, what’s going on out there,” he told me. The balmy waters produced during this year’s El Niño have essentially imported a whole ecosystem from Mexico. In recorded history, “this is the most profound movement of tropical fishes into California that anyone’s ever seen,” Milton Love, a research biologist at UC Santa Barbara’s Marine Science Institute, told me.”

Partlow, J. 2026. The Waters Off California Are Unrecognizable. The Atlantic, November  


LATIN AMERICA

Along the shores of a small estuary near Playa Langosta, just south of Costa Rica’s popular Tamarindo beach, residents came across an unsettling scene: two bull sharks (Carcharhinus leucas), rays, pufferfish and several other fish species had died, their bodies strewn across the sand in a haphazard burial by nature herself. For a region where sharks are familiar “neighbors” in the coastal waters, the discovery was concerning, especially because according to community reports, bull sharks had never previously been documented entering this particular estuary.

Marquez, M.C. 2026.Bull Sharks Found Dead In Costa Rica As Drought And El Niño Raise Environmental Concerns.Forbes, November 10 

RANDOM STUFF

When the El Niño drought ended in a remote Papua New Guinea rainforest, the trees did not immediately recover. Many kept dying.

That is one of the findings of a recent study of more than 21,000 trees in the Wanang Forest Dynamics Plot, a 50-hectare (124-acre) research site in northern Papua New Guinea.

Researchers measured tree mortality before, during and two years after the catastrophic 2015-17 El Niño drought and found that mortality was significantly higher after the drought than before or during it.

“It was after the drought, the post-drought period, that you could actually see those trees dying,” said Hayden Wagia, the study’s lead author and a faculty botanist at the Papua New Guinea University of Technology’s School of Forestry.

Burkhart, M. 2026. El Niño’s hidden toll on trees emerges years later in Papua New Guinea rainforest. Mongabay, November 9


Historical precedents are sobering, with major El Niño events of 1982-83, 1997-98 and 2015-16 leading to extreme flooding in some regions, severe drought in others, and widespread disruption to ecosystems and economies.

Now imagine if hospitals were overrun with respiratory events due to wildfire smoke, migraines, heatstroke and delirium. At the same time, the electricity grid could go down due to overwhelming demand from the use of air conditioning systems.

If that scenario sounds plausible, it’s because every element has already happened in Canada, just not all at once. We call these scenarios polycrises, to represent multiple connected crises occurring simultaneously. We’ve seen these before, such as the 2013 Calgary floods, the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic and the 2023 Northwest Territories wildfires that required evacuation.

Gohel B and Demarco T. 2026.  El Niño 2026-27 as a polycrisis: What happens when health and energy systems fail simultaneously? The Conversation, November 8


COP31: The invisible impact of El Niño on women

Delegates are told women in poorer nations in particular will face more hardship as the climate shocks increase this season

Aouatif Zebiri, spokesperson for YOUNGO, said: “According to FAO, 44% of working youth earn their living from food and agriculture, while 395 million of rural young people live in areas where climate change is expected to reduce harvests.

“So we, as youth are not simply the future of food systems, we are already part of sustaining them.  Yet, when climate shock affect every culture, the consequences go far far beyond food production.

“Water scarcity can increase the time women and girls spend collecting water – declining household incomes for example can compromise children’s nutrition, health and education – and limited access to water and sanitation can make it very hard for adolescent girls to manage their menstrual health safely and with dignity.”

Morley, S. 2026. COP31: The invisible impact of El Niño on women – Energy Live News November 9 


5 ways El Niño could impact the energy sector | Spectra by MHI 

1. Electricity demand could climb

2. Renewables could come under pressure

3. Coal and gas could fill the gap

4. Grid resilience could be tested

5. Flexibility could become more valuable


El Niño also affects renewable energy production by changing sunshine, winds and atmospheric circulation.

We expect available solar energy to fall by 5–15% from January to March, alongside a slowdown in available wind energy. Other sources may therefore be needed to meet residential, commercial and industrial electricity demand this winter.

Singh, H. and St. George, S. 2026. Physics-based models prepare us for El Niño. Insurance Day, November 12


MONEY

Institute for International Economics estimates if the intensity is similar to the last super El Niño we had in the late 1990s, the economic damage could be close to a trillion dollars next year. And that comes from the physical damage caused by extreme temperatures, flooding, and drought; crop destruction; supply chain disruptions; and, of course, reduced investment and slower economic growth. And it’ll hit lower- and middle-income countries in the tropics especially hard. Here in the U.S., though, the San Francisco Federal Reserve estimates it could add one percentage point to inflation throughout 2027. So we’re definitely going to feel this over the coming year.

 Kimberly Adams, Amy Scott and Ariana Rosas  2026 How this year’s Super El Niño could impact the economy Marketplace, November 9


Fitch Ratings-New York/Mexico City-12 November 2026: Latin American sovereigns should have sufficient headroom to absorb the negative economic effects caused by a severe El Niño this year — including sharp economic growth decelerations and rise in inflation — without affecting their ratings, Fitch Ratings says. Fitch’s economic projections incorporate El Nino’s effects via direct and indirect channels, but could be subject to downside risk should this be more severe than anticipated.

LatAm Sovereign Ratings Can Absorb ‘Super El Niño’ Risks. Fitchratings, November 12

THIS SCEPTIC ISLE

Scientists have spoken out about the ‘unusual’ polar vortex which could have an unexpected impact on UK due to major changes in the stratosphere.

Winds circulating above the North Pole are splitting into two, which is pushing Arctic air towards Britain and parts of Europe.

The polar vortex is a band of strong winds that remain high in the atmosphere, keeping the trapped air near the North Pole, but when it weakens and breaks up there is a risk of it pushing colder air to the south.

After some of the hottest days on record this summer, and fears about the El Niño phenomenon wreaking havoc on weather and vital food production globally, sparking stockpiling warnings, exactly what’s in store for us this winter still can’t be confirmed just yet.

Holt, J. 2026. ‘Unusual’ polar vortex could have unexpected impact on UK as scientists warn ‘we’ve never seen anything like this before’. LAD Bible, November 8


The struggle is real

Rice Krispies and Coco Pops are facing a crunch crisis, as “changing weather” is forcing Kellanova – the UK producer of the iconic Kellogg’s cereals – to adjust their ingredients.

In a statement last week, a company spokesperson admitted that the cereals would no longer be made with whole rice grains but rather corn flour and rice flour instead.

The new recipe, the spokesperson added, would help the company “maintain consistent quality at a time when changing weather conditions are affecting the quality and availability of some of the rice and grains used in our cereals.”

Sauers, C. 2026. ‘Snap, crackle and drought’: Why El Niño could change what ends up on your breakfast table | Euronews November 9


‘The UK medicines supply chain is global by design’, explains Ross Maclagan, head of supply and distribution policy at the Association of the British Pharmaceutical Industry (ABPI). ‘Around 14,000 licensed medicines reach UK patients through international networks, and key components such as active pharmaceutical ingredients (APIs) are often sourced from countries including India and China. In normal times that interconnection is a strength, because it gives the system many routes to supply. It also means that events far from the UK can be felt here, with extreme weather and natural disasters among the many factors that can affect manufacturing and distribution.’

While Mr Maclagan believes ‘it would not be responsible to speculate on how any single weather event might affect individual products’, he says ‘what we do know is that disruptions are most common in generic medicines, which account for 75% of NHS prescriptions, and where supply is often spread across several manufacturers, so when one is affected, gaps can open quickly and be hard to predict – plus recovery also takes time: increasing production capacity can take 9 to 18 months.’

Risks to patients

For patients, even short interruptions in medicines supply can carry clinical consequences.

‘A person with epilepsy who misses doses risks breakthrough seizures’, says Mr Maclagan. ‘A transplant recipient without immunosuppressants risks organ rejection. A patient on antidepressants may experience withdrawal symptoms within days. The impact is also unequal: people with limited mobility, long-term conditions or inflexible working patterns may find it hardest to visit several pharmacies to find what they need.’

Nonetheless, he stresses it is important to keep this in proportion: ‘Around 95 per cent of potential disruptions are identified and resolved before they affect patients. Only around one to two per cent are classified as critical, and on average, issues are resolved within 28 days. That reflects close, daily collaboration between industry, the NHS, government and regulators.’

Jankovic, S. 2026. What effect will this year’s ‘super’ El Niño have on the medicines supply chain? The Pharmacist, November 10


Just as they appointed a Drought Minister in 1976…

ANTALYA, Nov 12: The United Kingdom on Thursday announced the appointment of a special envoy to tackle threats from climate change while small island leaders called for urgent action, describing the issue as a life-or-death issue for their people at the climate talks in the Turkish resort town of Antalya.

UK names climate security envoy as island leaders warn of ‘life-or-death’ crisis Daily Excelsior, November 12


“Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.”


“Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.”


LINKS

For a FAQ see here. The comedy of El Nino (no, really) it’s a 1997 video. El Nino acronyms  El Nino quotes

El Nino videos  El Nino timeline up to 2025

Disclaimers

I am not a climate scientist. I am mostly collating what other people say, not pushing my own “angle”. I will get things wrong – when I do, I’ll fess up, no fuss. I will quote from “reputable” sources, but sometimes the truth is an outlandish outlier.  

Blah blah information provided for lulz only. No responsibility taken for your failure to create broad-based social movements that prevent shit getting even worse and instead leading us into the pit of Sarlac.

The digest is inspired by the awe-inspiring and heart-breaking “CO2 Newsletter published by American geologist William Barbat from 1979 to 1982.

Categories
Germany

 November 15, 1976 – Dahlem conference – “Global chemical cycles and their alterations by man”

Fifty years ago, on this day, November 15th, 1976,

15 Nov 1976 – Global chemical cycles and their alterations by man : report of the Dahlem Workshop on Global Chemical Cycles and their Alterations by Man, Berlin 1976, November 15-19 /

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 331ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that concern had been building about carbon dioxide emissions through the 60s and into the 70s, and there had been fairly pivotal few meetings about man’s impact on the climate, especially in Sweden in 1971 and then the GARP meeting in 1974. American oceanographer Wally Broecker had had an article published in Science magazine in 1975 and people were getting their heads around the idea.

This conference really brought together a whole bunch of people, mostly European, but not entirely, to study the question. 

What I think we can learn from this is that it’s 50 years since we really got our heads around this issue. “We”, being the scientists, politicians, well, you could strongly argue that they still haven’t, and they never will, because it just doesn’t fit their cosmology, and because a lot of them are just thick venal assholes.

What happened next . More conferences, 1977 is the big year where it really kicks off, but unfortunately, all the conferences in the world didn’t lead to emissions reductions, which was what we needed all along. 

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 15, 1958 – Academic Paper on “Changes in Carbon Dioxide Content of Atmosphere and Sea Due to Fossil Fuel Combustion” submitted

November 15, 1979 – the FT reports on German concerns about fossil fuel effects.

November 15, 1983 – “Energy Futures and Carbon Dioxide” report…

November 15, 2004 – Bob Carr on Lateline- “no other developed country will be as severely affected by global warming as Australia.”

Categories
Australia Kyoto Protocol

 November 14, 2001 – Fin does a front page story on climate, supports Kyoto ratification

Twenty five years ago, on this day, November 14th, 20The Australian Financial Review gave the Marrakech conference front-page coverage on November 12 and editorialised in support of Australian ratification of the Kyoto Protocol on November 14. If greenhouse gas emissions must be reduced, the AFR argued, then the smoke-and-mirrors “flexibility mechanisms” are the cheapest route.

The AFR’s editors argued that Australia might face trade penalties such as increased tariffs if it refused to ratify the Kyoto Protocol, although this possibility has generally only been raised by conservative “think-tanks” such as the International Chamber of Commerce and the (Australian) Lavoisier Group.

The AFR’s editors also wondered “exactly how negatively the international community would regard a country that extracted maximum concessions in negotiations over the first commitment period, then declined to ratify, and then tried to muscle back into the negotiations for the second commitment period next decade”.

Jim green – https://www.greenleft.org.au/content/greenhouse-kyoto-protocol-rescued-again

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 371ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that the rich nations – well, one rich nation in particular, the United States – had scuppered the possibility of targets and timetables being in the original text of the climate treaty signed at Rio in 1992 There had then been an effort to get targets and timetables for rich countries into force, i.e. the Kyoto Protocol of 1997.

However, after winning the 2000 election by five votes to four in the Supreme Court, the Bush administration, or perhaps we should say the Cheney-Bush administration, had then rapidly pulled the US out of the Kyoto Protocol, despite the fact that on the campaign trail Bush had said that carbon dioxide emissions would need to be regulated. 

The specific context. Here we see the Australian Financial Review talking about Kyoto, because there’s another COP conference happening, in Marrakesh, Morocco. By this time it was fairly clear that the Howard administration was not going to ratify Kyoto, even though they’d been a really good deal extorted, and the Australian Financial Review representing particular – well financial – forms of capital was of the opinion that there was money to be made from carbon trading and carbon offsetting, and so forth. Even though the Sydney Futures Exchange had gone under, there was still hope that you could ratify Kyoto, get some money making schemes selling New South Wales forests as carbon offsetting for Japanese emissions, all that jazz, and this is also the point at which the Business Council of Australia was fighting itself to a standstill over this very question of Kyoto ratification and support for renewables, and so forth.

What I think we can learn from this is that capital is divided, not as divided as some people would like to make out, but more divided than others would.

What happened next was that in June 2002 Prime Minister John Howard said that he would not, in fact, ratify Kyoto. In 2003 he kiboshed the emissions trading scheme that the rest of his cabinet wanted.

It was only in 2007 that Australia finally ratified Kyoto, and it was worth a bucket of warm spit. 

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 14, 1977 – Met Office boss forced to think about #climate change – first interdepartmental meeting…

November 14, 1984 – first World Industry Conference on Environmental Management begins in Versailles, France.

November 14, 1997 – Aussies want WTO to scupper UNFCCC

November 14, 2005 – Downing St blocked with coal

November 14, 2013, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse’s 50th #climate speech

November 14, 2014 – US and China sign climate deal, in part to troll Australian Prime Minister

Categories
Australia

November 14, 1994 – Report begs government to nurture green industries

Thirty two years ago, on this day, November 14th, 1994,

The Federal Government could generate thousands of jobs in environmentally friendly industries if it removed development impediments and boosted funding, a bipartisan parliamentary inquiry has found.

The report by the House of Representatives environment, recreation and arts standing committee says 20,000 jobs could be created by 2000 in the pollution-control industry.

Australia needed to capture only 2 per cent of the world market by 2000 to generate 150,000 jobs and $8 billion in business.

The committee’s report, tabled in Parliament yesterday, says the Government needs to coordinate more effectively its environment and economic policies.

“A tax on emissions of greenhouse gases or an energy tax in the form of a carbon tax could be introduced as a substitute for other taxes such as payroll tax, which are a disincentive to employment,” it says.

The committee’s chairman, Mr John Langmore (ALP, ACT), called on governments to swap rhetoric for action and overcome “bureaucratic inertia”.

1994 Boreham, G. 1994. Report Calls On Government To Nurture Green Industries. The Age, 15 November, p.5.

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 359ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that the Ecologically Sustainable Development process, where lots of these ideas about green capitalism had been put forward, had been kneecapped and then shot in the head by Paul Keating and his allies within the federal bureaucracy.

But if you are a believer in liberal capitalism and the power of the state, such as it is, then you keep on talking about nurturing green industries, because that lets you have red green alliance stories that you can soothe yourself with nice little lullabies, and you get some reports and some media coverage and a sense of progress and or influence out of it, even though it’s not going to happen, or certainly not the way you think it needs to, and not at the speed it need, you think it needs to. 

What I think we can learn from this is that people are good at lullabies. 

What happened next The green industries were not, in fact, nurtured. 

xxx

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 14, 1977 – Met Office boss forced to think about #climate change – first interdepartmental meeting…

November 14, 1984 – first World Industry Conference on Environmental Management begins in Versailles, France.

November 14, 1997 – Aussies want WTO to scupper UNFCCC

November 14, 2005 – Downing St blocked with coal

November 14, 2013, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse’s 50th #climate speech

November 14, 2014 – US and China sign climate deal, in part to troll Australian Prime Minister

Categories
Kyoto Protocol UNFCCC

The COPs – where they come from, why they were futile from 2002 at the absolute latest, etc.

The following is a tidied up transcript of an interview conducted last week.

Question – Was there a time when this was worthwhile and it seemed like it could be working and we were going to actually get somewhere and do something, or was it doomed from before it even started?

My reply -So scientists have known about carbon dioxide buildup in the atmosphere as a problem since the early 1950s.  This was not a state secret. It was not hidden away from anyone. It was in American newspapers, Australian newspapers. It was on the radio. It was on the television. But it wasn’t until the late 1970s that scientists were sure that it was going to be a problem…

So the first thing to understand is that it’s a global problem in every sense. In that, emissions that come out of one country don’t stay there; they very quickly mix into the atmosphere. 

So it was very quickly understood, once they realised that it was going to be a problem, that it was a global problem, and it was going to need coordination and cooperation from nations, big and small. And in the end, what happened was that in 1988, for various reasons, climate change burst onto the scene. It was a minor issue in the 1988 election between Bush – George Herbert Walker Bush – and Michael Dukakis.

And Bush won that election, and Bush was an oil man and was sympathetic – even more than the Democrats – to big auto, big oil, and they could see a problem for themselves. Their fear was that the world would take action on carbon dioxide in the same way the world had taken action on ozone, which had been an issue a couple of years before. 

So it was very very important for the Americans and the Saudis and the Gulf oil and gas exporters, that whatever deal emerged from an international negotiating process was as weak as possible, and Bush did everything he could to slow down even the beginning of the negotiations, including censoring James Hansen, the climate scientist, in 1989, back when Hanson was still employed by NASA. Bush got caught doing that, and it blew up in his face. And so eventually, the United States was forced to concede that there should, in fact, be an international treaty to tackle climate change.

The United States has always been extremely reluctant around international treaties, and especially about environmental ones. And the ozone thing wasn’t a really; it was an international treaty, but there were very very small numbers of active participants because only a few countries had significant CFC production, whereas climate, everyone realised, was going to be a much more difficult problem to solve. 

So what happened was that some countries, and France was in the lead, said “if we’re going to have an international treaty about carbon dioxide and climate change, the treaty has to include targets and timetables for steep emissions reductions by rich countries.” Everyone agreed that the rich countries which had caused the problem would have to go first. So the French said, “Let’s have a treaty, and it will include targets and timetables for emissions reductions.” And the response of the U.S. administration was, “If you present a treaty text that has targets and timetables for emissions reductions by rich countries. We will not come to the big summit in Rio. We will not sign it. We will not ratify it. And basically, it will be dead in the water.” 

And so, the French and the other advocates of targets and timetables for emissions reductions had to make a decision. They either had to proceed with a treaty that was strong but did not include the United States and therefore would be weak or worthless, or they would back down, take out the targets and timetables, get the Americans in the room, get the Americans to sign it, and then later get targets and timetables in. 

Now this is absolutely crucial history, which you never see talked about, and it enrages me because everyone assumes that “oh, 1992 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change. Yes, that was a long time ago, we don’t really know what happened. We don’t really need to look into how it was made.” Yes, we do. 

There were these things called “newspapers” at the time, and and people would talk to the newspaper reporters, and it’s all absolutely clear. And then you get people saying, “Oh well, you know, it was  different times, and they didn’t really know what was going on.” They absolutely knew; they had the first IPCC report in 1990 in front of them. This was straightforward naked power politics. The Americans and the Saudis, etc., wanted to make sure that they could keep on selling and using fossil fuels for as long as they wanted, and they didn’t want to have to negotiate on actual emissions reductions. 

So here we are in early 1992, and the British minister responsible was a guy called Michael Howard, and he flies to New York, and he negotiates the removal of targets and timetables from the text of the draft text of the treaty. At which point the Americans say, “Fine, we will come to Rio. We will sign it. We’ll ratify it because it is toothless” – they didn’t say this out loud, but essentially they were no longer worried that their hands might be tied because the treaty was now toothless. 

So some people, and I think I am among them, would say that’s the crucial moment, and everything that follows from that is what we call kayfabe, is “make believe.” 

Other people would say, “no, no, no, you’re being too doctrinaire. You don’t understand that these things do take time. That you have to use soft power and cajoling to get the big boys to do the right thing.” And so this comes back – I don’t know how much international relations theory you know – but there’s the realism school, and then there’s the liberal institutionalism, and those guys would bat this back and forth. 

And at the time, there were diplomats writing on both perspectives. So if you want to be charitable, you can say that it all was not lost. 

So then, what happened is that the treaty was opened for signatures at Rio, June of 1992, and the whole thing got signed and ratified by enough nations to become international law a fair bit quicker than anyone had anticipated. I think, I mean, I wasn’t paying close attention at the time, but there was a kind of assumption. “Well, this is going to take, you know, three or four or five years until we start having meetings about the treaty.” But that was not what happened. What happened was that by late 1994, enough nations had signed, and therefore the very first COP, which stands for Conference of the Parties, was held in Berlin in March April 1995 And one of the key movers, German politicians involved in that was Angela Merkel.

And the thing that came out of Berlin was this thing called the Berlin Mandate, and the Berlin Mandate was an effort to put back into the treaty the idea that rich countries would have to commit to targets and timetables for emissions reductions of their own. And for reasons I don’t fully understand, they were able to get that through, and it was agreed that at the third COP, in and we should remember that it wasn’t certain that the COPs would be an annual thing. Nowhere is it written that the COP has to be annual. I mean, it has been annual every year except the pandemic. 

So there was then another negotiating process, and there is a rich documentary record here, and this was under Clinton and Gore. And Clinton Gore had already tried to introduce a domestic tax. I don’t know if you remember the BTU tax, and they’d had their asses handed to them by the fossil fuel lobby. So the second COP after Berlin was held in Geneva, Switzerland, and everyone was haggling and arguing with each other. 

And the third COP was scheduled for Kyoto in December of 1997, and this is the point where the rich nations were supposed to turn up with their plans for “we’ll cut by X percent by such and such a date, etc.” And everyone turned up, and the Australians played hardball. The Americans, very very complicated. I’m telling a vastly simplified story. But the Americans turned up saying yes, they would do some cuts. The European Union continued to be sort of the leader on this, and they said, “Well, we as the EU as a whole will reduce our emissions by, I think it was they promised 12% by 2008.” And the poor nations were there, but the poor nations were not having to take on any emissions cuts of their own because the argument was they hadn’t caused the problem. They needed to grow their economies to lift people out of poverty. 

And in the run-up to the Kyoto conference, you had this huge front group called the Global Climate Coalition, which was, you know, Exxon, Mobil before they combined, GM, Ford, all the usual suspects, and they were determined that the U.S. not sign a treaty or a protocol to the treaty that committed the U.S. to emissions reductions. And so they were able to rally the tame senators. And there was this thing called the Byrd-Hagel resolution in the U.S. Senate that said the U.S. will not sign any carbon emissions reductions treaty that does not impose similar constraints on poor countries because they could see China coming. China was industrialising quickly. I mean, it didn’t really take off until into the 2000s, but you could see it coming.

 So if you wanted to believe the Liberal Institutionalist theory that “get a treaty, get everyone’s signature on it, exert soft power, cajoling carrots and sticks, and etc.” you could still argue that the UNFCCC process was kinda-sorta heading in the right direction, albeit slower than it should have, and that the COPs were a worthwhile thing. 

I think that the COP process becomes really a dead letter, except for all of the absolutely most Pollyanna-ish paid to believe it can still work people, when Dubya Bush pulled out of Kyoto negotiations in March of 2001. If you wanted me to pick “the day the UNFCCC died,” I think that would be my day. 

Now, very quickly, what happened is, and then the Australians pulled out the following year. But the Russians wanted to be part of the World Trade Organisation. The EU said “we’ll support that as long as you sign Kyoto.” The Russians said, “Yeah, but our economy collapsed after 1990, so we have lots of freedom to pollute and still meet our Kyoto obligations because of all those factories that shut down. So yeah, fine, we’ll sign Kyoto. It means nothing, but we’ll sign it.” And the Europeans were very happy with themselves. So then, in 2005, the Kyoto Protocol finally became international law. That’s both L A W and L O R E, and as in fairy tale. And then it becomes a question of well, the Kyoto Protocol was going to be for the years 2008 to 2012, and something’s going to have to replace that. 

So then you have all of the shit, sorry, the summit around Copenhagen. And then it turns out, and you can quote me on this: the Danes are not nearly as clever and diplomatic as they think they are, and the whole thing falls apart, and everyone blames everyone else, and there are some lovely sound bites, and then it’s just in the toilet

And then the French decide, “well, we’re gonna pick up the vase and glue all the bits of the vase back together, so it looks like a vase still, and we’ll host the COP in Paris in 2015.”

And then in 2015 you get the Paris Agreement, which famously, as Naomi Klein pointed out, does not include the word fossil fuels. So we’ve had decades of conversation about how to cope with climate change, and they’ve never put the word fossil fuels in the treaties and in the text until you know years later.

In 1991, the negotiations were hopelessly bogged down, and they had a hard deadline because they’d already agreed to hold what was called the Earth Summit in June of 1992 in Rio, and that was a fixed point. And so different people were coming up with different ways to try and break the logjam and to create something that was, frankly, that Bush would sign, that still meant there could be progress

And the Japanese proposed this thing called “Pledge and Review.” The idea was that rather than have targets and timetables and strict agreements, you all turn up in Rio and every nation would have brought its own pledge about what it would do, and then a few years later there would be a review to see whether the nations had done those pledges and whether it was enough. Because alongside the UNFCCC process, you also had the IPCC, the scientific process, and the scientists were saying, “Look, look, you’ve got to cut deep quickly, and if you cut deep quickly, you’ve got a chance. But the more, the longer you leave it, the harder it is.” I always make the analogy of you know you’re trying to lose weight for your to fit into a wedding dress, and if you lose a pound a week, it’s easy. But if you leave it till the end, you’re going to have to do liposuction or get a bigger dress, and you can’t get a bigger dress.

So the Japanese proposed pledge and review, and they were laughed out of the room. People thought, “look, that is a recipe for complete capitulation and failure.” 

And guess what? Pledge and review was dusted off, given a new name, and called the Intended nationally determined contributions. It is the Paris Agreement was signed and agreed on the basis of pledge and review, where nobody has to commit to anything serious, and nobody can be held to account if they don’t even meet those inadequate pledges, because there is no big boss. This is what the Realists would say versus the Liberal Institutionalists. There is no one who’s going to knock heads together. There’s never going to be any tariffs or sanctions on a nation that is free riding. 

So, we got Paris, and I said at the time with Paris that I strongly expect it will run into the sand within three or four years.

Why does the COP caravan keeps going?

Well, for the longest time it’s been the only show in town. And the poor nations have no choice but to turn up because they’re disappearing under the waves. There have, of course, been repeated proposals for how you would reform or change the UNFCCC. There’s an academic called David Victor who’s written a lot about this, and there’s this idea of carbon clubs, but nobody trusts anyone, and the the two Trump administrations have been more open about their contempt than say Bush was or Biden was. Obama’s a little bit interesting. Obama just wasn’t willing to spend any political capital on it – he was saving all his political capital to get Obamacare through, and he felt that he could only do one thing at a time. Which, given the politics of the day and the numbers in the House and the Senate and so forth, that that’s where we’re at. 

I think also you have to understand that COP has morphed into a clean tech – “clean” in inverted commas,  trade show and expo. And there was a COP three or four years ago in Azerbaijan.  So there’d been cops held in fossil fuel intensive places before. There was the one in Poznan, Poland in 2008, and then the Poles also held again in 2017. I want to say I could be hazy

But the increase not just in lobbyists but in all of the salesmen for the various you know carbon capture and storage, direct air capture, and all of the other stuff. And that I think is one of the reasons why COP continues is it’s just become a predictable, Useful, familiar place on the calendar where you can go and not sign deals, but do the negotiations for deals and to maintain relationships and to extend relationships. 

But it has, I mean, virtually nothing to do with addressing climate change because what needed to happen for addressing climate change was to reduce emissions sharply against a 1988 baseline. But as you said earlier, you know we’ve emitted so much additional CO2, but you know things persist long after they have ceased to have the function that they initially had. Just inertia, and it becomes useful for other reasons. 

… I mean the renewables people will want to be there, and there are still, you know, if you’re 40 years old and you still truly believe that solar is going to save the world by replacing fossil fuels, and you know you can point to just how much solar is entering the energy grids of China and Pakistan and so forth then you can make an argument to yourself that you’re doing your bit by turning up at COP and schmoozing energy and environment ministers from countries that are looking to move away from fossil fuels. 

You can tell yourself that story, and it’s a good career move as well, and then the activists, where possible, want to be there because again, what else are you going to do? Well, I think there are lots of things you could do, but it’s too much like hard work. 

For politicians, attending COP  will be enough to make people who are low information on climate, which most sensible people are – because why would you spend your days thinking about the end of everything? Because that’s what climate is. It is the end of everything. So a rational person looks away, and only looks up if one of their politicians, who they feel generally warm and fuzzy, whether it’s El Sayed or or Ocasio Cortez or whatever, is standing in front of a picture of a wind turbine going “green industrial revolution”, and they think to themselves, “Oh, that’s nice. Things will be okay.” Of course, they do. 

It’s a networking opportunity for everyone. Everyone has their little tribe, and the tribe agrees to meet at such and such a place, and they exchange gossip and business cards and tips, and some people get laid, and the sex workers do very nicely out of the COPs, of course. People away from home, opportunity to you know “sample the local cultures” as the euphemism goes. So I’m not surprised that it continues without it meaning anything because it’s like the stamps in the envelope in the Graham Greene novel –  it serves a different function.

I mean, is there any value to keep having the COPs? I’ve become quite nihilistic. I used to be a physiotherapist, and we used to have patients come who’d had their legs amputated because they had smoked and smoked and smoked and continued to smoke after the doctor told them what the consequences would be. What I’m trying to say is, there is such a thing as a window of opportunity that closes. There is such a thing as physics, and if you go back and look at those warnings that the scientists were making in the 1980s, and the urgency with which they were saying “we must radically reduce emissions NOW”, and we’ve turned around and for the past almost 40 years done the exact opposite. There comes a point where the consequences are just gonna be there. It’s my concept of the Fafocene.

You know, and we can continue to have these meetings and make these pledges about the future, but that’s not going to change the fact that there are consequences literally baked in, literally baked in. So, if I were space aliens offering our species advice. It wouldn’t include have an annual meeting where 50, 60, 70,000 people turn up where some of those people genuinely want the world to be a better place, but the rest of them are trying to flog a technology, whether it’s nuclear, whether it’s carbon capture, whatever.

In defence of the COPs, people will say, “No, no, no. We’re going to have a Democrat in the White House by 2029, and they’re going to care about climate change, and therefore the U.S. will be back.”  

I think there are things that we need to do about climate change, and those things are not going to happen at the COPs, and they’re not going to be discussed at the COPs or decided at the COPs. And even if they were decided at the COPs, it wouldn’t filter down. What is still. needed around climate action is for especially middle class people in countries where political action is possible because there’s freedom of speech, freedom of information, freedom of assembly, to be heavily involved in pushing for or doing and pushing for radical action and degrowth, and a massive reduction in the sort of the casual consumption that happens in the West around meat eating, around driving tanks, around unnecessary flying. None of that will happen because people’s identities are so closely tied up with how much they consume. The more that you consume, the more successful a person you are, the happier a person you are, the more you have proof that God loves you. And if you start reducing your consumption, you are a luddite and a communist, and you will lose all your friends. You will lose career opportunities. If there’s two of you going for a promotion and you say, “I’d rather not fly to that conference to give that presentation,” the competitor is going to say, “I’ll fly,” and they’ll get the job, and the carbon will have still gone into the air, and you’ll be washed up. 

So the incentive structures are there for us to keep going. 

[Digression about Erisychthon]

Yeah, yeah. So you know, for 1000s of years, I mean, Ovid was writing at the time of Christ, you know, A.D. 08, and he was probably drawing on a myth from 1000 years before. Look at the famous Mesopotamian one, Epic of Gilgamesh. Our myths across the world are full of warnings about the consequences of appetites that are not constrained or controlled. Even in Europe after the Industrial Revolution, there were warnings about this. You know the religious stuff about Mammon. You can worship God or Mammon, and on and on and on. To come back to the 1950s. Since the 1950s we have been telling ourselves a story that our technology has solved the problems of scarcity. 

There’s two kinds of science. There’s production science, nuclear, genetic modification, radar, sonar, so you could hunt down fish more effectively, etc., etc., etc. And there’s impact science, where we could start to measure the consequences of deploying up production science.

So possibly the earliest examples of this are with radioactive fallout, and you can detect strontium 90 in the teeth of children. And then you get Rachel Carson talking about DDT, and production science and impact science have been in competition, and we’ve chosen to think that whatever we do to ourselves, there’s always a technological fix, and there doesn’t need to be any constraint on our appetites. 

And the COP is this weird holdover. I mean, COP – what’s it going to be? Number 31. Okay, so the clue is in the name. 31 times we’ve done this. 

So, for your putative reader in, I forget whether you said Alabama or Mississippi, they could think of COP as the alcoholic promising that they’ll change. “That’s the last time I get drunk. That’s the last time I drive home over the limit. That’s the last time I hit or threaten to hit my wife or my husband.” And if they’ve done that 30 times, are you going to believe  are you going to believe in the 31st, or are you going to say “no, we need to do something different. You need to get your ass into recovery. You need to go to a 12-step programme.”

Now, the ‘whole humans are addicted to fossil fuels’ thing is is quite tricky because it’s a subset of humans that have forced the rest of us to be addicted. “He gives the kids free samples because he knows full well that today’s young innocent faces will be tomorrow’s clientele.”

But if you’re bringing it down to a personal level, if there have been 30 meetings and emissions are twice as high as they were when the meetings began, and the consequences are piling up all around us, that’s got to say something. 

And yet, the meetings are still useful for the renewables crew,  or for whatever, and the academics can get some publications out of it and feel like they’re contributing

But really,  to use another metaphor, it’s the emperor’s new clothes. Nobody wants to be the seven-year-old kid who says “the emperor is naked,” because in the real world that seven-year-old kid is not applauded and thanked. That seven-year-old kid is sectioned, or  given some antidepressants and put in a “special school.”

Look, even when the cop was held in the UK, the UK the UK Environmental campaigning groups like Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace and so forth were not really able to make much of it to turn it into a sort of a recruitment tool or a you know mobilising tool because again once your numbers start getting into double figures, people have to ask themselves, “Well, this is this is just another. It’s like an FA Cup final. There’ll be another one along, you know. It doesn’t mean anything.” 

And so I think the last time people really got excited about a COP was Paris in 2015, and that’s because of the particular sequence of events. Copenhagen had been such a failure, and here come the French to salvage it all. And you could still, if you were a bit scientifically illiterate, and you needed to hope,l believe that 2015, if we took quick decisive action and we were very very lucky, luckier than we deserved at a species level, that the situation was salvageable.

But I think you’d struggle to find anyone who has more than a rudimentary understanding of the science to say that the situation was salvageable, if you had them on their own, anonymous. Once people are in groups, they know that they’ve got a reputation to defend, they’ve got to be part of the tribe. 

There are exceptions. There are people like Ed Miliband, who’s now foreign secretary. He is just always insanely optimistic. There’s a couple of other people, but if you scratch the surface, they are assuming that there will be rollouts of their favoured technology at incredible speed. So Bill McKibben is all in on solar, and you know solar is spreading so quickly that maybe he’s right, but even then, you’re still only going to reduce by a bit.

Say solar exceeds everyone’s expectations, and they even have them now, and say that I’m just making up numbers. Say it knocks 10 billion tonnes off the annual release of CO2, so we’re down to 30 billion tonnes being released every year. That’s still 10 billion more tonnes that was too much in 1990, and it’s the accumulation of it. 

So if we get all that solar and we get down to you know bullshit about net zero. You’re still left with the consequences of what you’ve done before. 

So another story from when I was a physio. I remembered this really clearly because I just started as a physio and I was on the cardiothoracic rotation, and I had a patient, and I can remember his name. I won’t say it; it doesn’t matter. But anyway, he’d had a lung removed, and I went to him and said, “You know, check your name, date of birth, blah blah blah.” Pass. Do you smoke? And he said, “No,” really emphatically. And I was very young as a physio, I’d been on the job like a week, but I said, “Okay, did you smoke?” And he said, “Yes, until last week.” And the point is, we feel that if we take action now, that negates the build-up in the past, but it doesn’t. The damage, you know, there is such a thing as the damage is done. So you can have all the solar that you want. The Arctic and the Antarctic are still melting. Nepal, the Third Pole, Tibet. That’s going to continue. The ocean acidification is going to continue. The desert, you know. The damage is done, but we cling to these stories of salvation at the last minute.

You know, the film Armageddon, the Bruce Willis one, where they blow up the asteroid. We cling to these stories that with you know one weird trick, we can save ourselves because that’s yeah. Well, they have to be because the alternative is massive demand reduction in the rich countries, and massive demand reduction in the rich countries means smaller houses, smaller cars, less flying, less meat. Well, try selling that to a Western popular electorate. It’s a suicide note as a manifesto, isn’t it?

So look, the COPs continue because they meet many many social needs, whether it’s for journalists or trade lobbyists or politicians wanting a photo op. The fact that it’s been going on for so long tells you that it is continuing to meet needs. Those needs are shifting. It will possibly continue, though it’s getting a little bit harder to find someone who wants to host it because it’s very expensive. There’s a certain amount of reputational risk. It comes with a certain amount of attention to your own country’s performance on climate. But I, it wouldn’t surprise me if COP didn’t keep going for another, you know, five or 10. 

What would surprise me, and now I am going to sound like a complete fucking lunatic. I would be very surprised we are in 2026. I would be very surprised if by 2036, the world economy and the world travel networks are such that people are willing and able to travel for an event of that size in the numbers that they’re travelling. I think we’re. I think El Nino is going to force a lot of people, at least briefly, to wake up and see the depth of the crisis that we’re in. So maybe that will give added impetus to next year’s COP, which is, I think, in Ethiopia. Maybe the El Nino will scare the shit out of everyone, but then memories fade. But I, but I wouldn’t bet against us hitting two degrees by 2036. We’ve had a couple of days now, consecutive days over two degrees, and I could easily see just shit falling apart. I don’t know exactly what that looks like, but I could see international travel becoming really dangerous and difficult, and governments just not being interested in participating, and sort of the acknowledged collapse of the COP process.

Look at the IPCC, the opponents of action have managed to kick it into the long grass beyond the next stock take, the IPCC. 

It’s a relatively similar story to the UNFCCC around the interference by the usual suspects: the Americans, the Saudis, and the attacks on the science were kind of more vicious and explicit, especially in the 1990s. I’m amazed that they’re still bothering to do these reports. There will be the seventh assessment report, or will it be the eighth? I think it’ll be the seventh. I mean, I’ve kind of lost count. Um, how many times can you say the same thing? And you know, this time, oh, they’re going to include the humanities and the social sciences. Yeah, but most of that is neoliberal positivistic wank anyway. So it’s garbage in, garbage out….  it’s angels on the head of a pin. This is what academics do because they need to believe that they are somehow influencing policymakers. I’m not sure future generations will see it that way. When we say to them, “You’re you’re absolutely fucked,” and here’s the documentations from like 1990, 95, 2001, 2007, 2013. You know, so we documented it for you guys. No, I think they’re going to get a little miffed at that.

As for all these reports, what they’re having to say is, what  UNEP emissions gap one was like. “You know, we need a 16% reduction in the next three years”, and it’s like, well, even in the depths of COVID, they managed 6% for one year. So it’s kind of the song by Leonard Cohen. “Everybody knows.” – everybody knows the war is over. Everybody knows a good guy’s lost.

It went from oh, “we’ll use technology”. Oh, “we’ll do carbon trading.” Oh, “we’ll do CCS.” “Oh, we’ll do direct air capture.” “Oh, we’ll do geoengineering.” There’s always a new trend. There’s always a new technology or policy that everyone can get excited about, and they get glossy reports. Politicians get to give speeches and send out mailers to low information voters. Kayfabe, you know, from wrestling – everybody knows that it’s make believe, but everybody knows that they have to continue to be part of the make believe, and nobody expects anyone else to believe it. That’s kayfabe.

Categories
Australia Kyoto Protocol

 November 13, 2000 – What will Kyoto achieve? “Hardly make any difference” says Aus scientist

Twenty six years ago, on this day, November 13th, 2000,

According to Graeme Pearman, Australia’s senior climate scientist and head of its greenhouse research effort, not much. On ABC `7.30 Report’ last night (13th) he concluded –

Dr Graeme Pearman: “The reality of the protocol as it is at the moment, is even if all of the nations were able to achieve those targets, it would hardly make any difference.” 

[Veil of Kyoto article]

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 370ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that there had been an attempt to get a global climate treaty with teeth in the period 1989 to 1992 There was a treaty, but the teeth had been taken out by the American dentist known as George H. W. Bush. He had insisted that there be no targets and timetables for emission emissions reductions by rich countries in the treaty text. If there were, he said he would boycott the Earth Summit, and so they were taken out. You were left with this process whereby targets and timetables had to be negotiated later, and this achingly slow progress had culminated, for what it was worth, in the Kyoto Protocol of 1997 and here we were three years later,

The specific context was the US election had been held, but it wasn’t clear who had won. 

What I think we can learn from this as predicted, our global institutions have not succeeded in the vital and somewhat difficult task of reducing carbon dioxide emissions.

What happened next George W. Bush, thanks to his dad’s mates on the Supreme Court, became president. The emissions kept on climbing and climbing and climbing. 

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 13, 1946 – first human-made snowstorm

November 13, 1963 –  Ritchie Calder warns of trouble ahead because of carbon dioxide…

November 13, 1975 – climate testimony to House of Reps committee

November 13, 1995 – no Aussie savings of greenhouse gases so far

November 13, 2000- Kyoto “would hardly make any difference.“

November 13, 2008 – Coal industry tries to get some ‘love’

Categories
Activism Netherlands

November 12, 2012 – URGENDA writes to the government

Fourteen years ago, on this day, November 12th, 2012

Letter to the government

URGENDA

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 395ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that the Dutch had been warned by their queen about climate change in 1988 in her Christmas address, and her husband had been warning about it in 1970. So it’s not like the Dutch weren’t acutely aware of all this. Dutch capital had done what Dutch capital does, made money in the short term, and there had been a failed energy transition because the academics had sat down with Shell and done what they were told. 

The specific context was here we see Urgenda having woken up and smelt the coffee, writing to the government. 

What I think we can learn from this is that states, however good their PR is, are ultimately about the accumulation of capital these days, and to some extent, military prowess (depends where you are). And they will say whatever needs saying, but they are often institutionally and almost always I would argue cognitively captured by the needs of capital. 

What happened next Urgenda won a court case, for what that was worth.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 12,1976 – “Greenhouse Effects due to Man-Made Perturbations of Trace Gases” in Science

November 12, 1998 – USA signs Kyoto

November 12, 1999 – John Howard and mates say “nope” to renewables

November 12, 2012 – Greenpeace smeared by Queensland extractors, of course