Categories
China United States of America

November 11, 2014 – Obama and Xi issue a joint statement

Twelve years ago, on this day, November 11th, 2014,

On November 11, in Beijing, China, presidents Barack Obama and Xi Jinping issued a joint statement. In it, they pledged to set new targets for cutting carbon dioxide levels. Their lead could be important. Together, these two nations now emit more than one-third of all the world’s CO2 emissions. https://www.snexplores.org/article/world-leaders-call-action-climate-change

https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2014/11/11/us-china-joint-announcement-climate-change

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 399ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that the US had ratified the UNFCCC which called for countries to have “common but differentiated responsibilities” in 1992. Then they had used China’s rise as an excuse not to sign the Kyoto Protocol. China kept rising. The Chinese Communist Party bosses are many things, but climate denialists is not one of them.

The specific context was that Obama and Xi were on their way to the G-20, being hosted by Australia in Brisbane. Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott wanted to keep climate change off the agenda. This was Obama’s response.

What I think we can learn from this – Tony Abbott is both stupid and evil. Er, that’s it.

What happened next: Despite the theatre, emissions kept climbing. Of late, China has been churning out rather a lot of solar panels.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 11, 1963 – “Is man upsetting the weather?”

November 11, 1965 – blackout!

November 11, 1988 – Gore blames Reagan and Reaganites for loss of US leadership

November 11, 1988 – IPCC finishes its first meeting

Categories
Australia

November 10, 1989 – Rural industries workshop on climate change

Thirty seven years ago, on this day, November 10th, 1989,

10 Nov 1989 Rural industries, workshop on climate change, Canberra, 10 November 1989.

Author: Australia. Bureau of Rural Resources.

ISBN: 9780646011189

Publication Information: Canberra : Bureau of Rural Resources, [1990].

Physical Description: iii, 52 pages : illustrations, maps ; 30 cm.

Series: BRR report ; no. R/3/90

Report (Australia. Bureau of Rural Resources) ; no.

https://www.vgls.vic.gov.au/client/en_AU/vgls/search/detailnonmodal/ent:$002f$002fSD_ILS$002f0$002fSD_ILS:125852/ada?qu=Rural+industries+–+Australia+–+Congresses.&d=ent%3A%2F%2FSD_ILS%2F0%2FSD_ILS%3A125852%7EILS%7E4&av=0&ps=300&h=8

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 351ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that Australia is a pretty interesting place to grow food. The weather matters (Goyder line etc) and there have been brutal droughts etc etc. So, changes in the weather, long-term, are always of interest.

The specific context was the carbon dioxide build-up problem had finally become an issue in 1987-88, and these sorts of conferences and workshops were happening all the time. This one is before ABARE became a site of ridiculous economic “modelling” aimed at protecting the fossil fuel industries.

What I think we can learn from this – organisations can be sane/useful and then get captured and repurposed. So it goes.

What happened next ABARE became one of the nodes in the network of denial, delay and obfuscation in the 1990s and into the 2000s.

xxx

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 10, 1969 – “Carbon Dioxide and All That”

November 10, 1988 – Activists demand even steeper emissions cuts than “Toronto.” Ignored, obvs. But were right…

November 10, 1994 – “profit or planet – choose one” (Victorian electricity)

November 10, 1995 – Ken Saro-Wiwa and other Ogoni executed

November 10, 1997 – moronic “Leipzig Declaration” by moronic denialists

Categories
Sweden

November 9, 1987 – Bellagio/SRI workshop begins

Thirty nine years ago, on this day, November 9th, 1987,

1987 Beginning of the Bellagio workshop

The 1987 Villach workshop assembled 48 experts from academia, environmental advocacy groups and some national environmental agencies (Jager, 1988). Workshop participants considerably advanced the scientific debate by examining the regional climatic impacts on coastal zones, mid-latitude, humid tropics and high latitude regions.

The Bellagio workshop meanwhile was significant in advancing the policy discussion for several reasons. It assembled 24 participants, half of them ‘regulars’ from previous workshops. More significantly, however, Bellagio succeeded in attracting new policy actors including representatives from the European Commission, Commonwealth Secretariat, German Parliament and the Swedish cabinet. Conclusions from Villach were used as a springboard to engage participants in probably the first explicit policy debate on climate change. A significant outcome of Bellagio was the proposal to design policies aimed at limiting increases in temperature and sea level to within ‘tolerable rates’, with 0.1°C/decade suggested as a suitable global threshold for temperature. Science had slowly been supplemented by policy entrepreneurship, but for the moment the momentum was with the experts who had convened nominally under the AGGG umbrella.

(see Agrawala 1999)

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 349ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that since the mid-1970s various think tanks and university departments had been paying serious attention to the problem of carbon dioxide build-up. There had been an attempt to get the World Meteorological Organisation to make bold pronouncements (it held a conference).

The specific context was the weight of evidence – and credibility – reached a tipping point in October 1985, with the Villach conference in Austria, hosted by WMO, UNEP and ICSU. After that, scientists started pulling on every lever they could, trying to get policymakers interested in/concerned about the climate issue. 

What I think we can learn from this is that we’ve been running the experiment for 40 years, and we have some good provisional results – our methods aren’t working.

What happened next – the following year the problem finally became an issue, with the drought in the US, James Hansen’s testimony, and then the speech by Margaret Thatcher.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 9, 1987- Senate hearings, for what they’re Wirth

November 9, 1988 – Tolba gives “Warming Warning” speech at first IPCC meeting

November 9, 1991 – Australian TV station SBS shows demented ‘”Greenhouse Conspiracy” ‘documentary’

November 9, 1992 – Ark sails on, Downunder

November 9, 1994 – interdepartmental bunfight in Australia

November 9, 2000 – Tyndall Centre launched

November 9, 2009 – Senior Liberal says CCS won’t work

Categories
Australia

November 8, 1988 – South Australian parliament legislation on ozone/greenhouse

Thirty eight years ago, on this day, November 8th, 1988,

Greenhouse move

ADELAIDE: Australian Democrats’ legislation to help contain the “greenhouse effect” looks set to succeed in the South Australian Parliament with the support of the Liberal Opposition.

The Bill, first presented to Parliament last year, seeks to limit the use and release of chlorofluorocarbons, which are considered largely responsible for holes in the protective ozone layer.

Canberra Times, 8 November 1988, p. 10

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 351ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that the South Australian parliament had been hearing warnings about carbon dioxide build up since 1971. These had increased in frequency through the late 70s, especially after the question of whether uranium could and should be exported began to heat up.

The specific context was that the Greenhouse 88 conferences had just happened. This was linked conferences linked by satellite around Australia and it’s hardly a surprise that legislation was being introduced.

Xxx

What I think we can learn from this is that it is now almost four decades since we began pretending to take action. 

What happened next South Australia didn’t really do that much on climate, not for want of trying by the bureaucrats.

However, in the early 2000s once Mike Rann became premier, there was much more interest in climate, Rann created the “Thinker in Residence” programme with Stephen Schneider as one of the first thinkers, and more importantly, Rann also started incentivizing wind power generation with some good arbitrage around the federal schemes. South Australia now has a hell of a lot of renewable energy generation.

xxx

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 8, 1989 – somebody suggests the polluters pay….

 November 8, 1989 – Thatcher gives climate speech to UN General Assembly

November 8, 1989 – ALP Minister says environmentalism a “middle-class fad” – “greenies” respond…

November 8, 2011 – Australian polluters are going to have to pay (briefly)

November 8, 2013 – “One religion is enough” says John Howard

Categories
Academia Activism

“Death to the IDM!”(*):  The Information Deficit Model, its attractions, consequences and persistence and ‘what is to be done’

I put up a Bluesky post that is doing better than normal. 

However (because?) I didn’t include a link to this blog post I wrote yesterday, about the “information deficit model” and the (UK) climate “movement” (or, rather, one organisation within the “movement.”).

In this post I am going to take a stab at answering four questions. Not the final word, not even my final words. Am genuinely interested in what you, dear reader(s?) think. Let me know in the comments or on Bluesky.

  • What is it?
  • What are its consequences?
  • If it is so bad, why does it persist?
  • What is to be done?

[*To be clear to any spooks who may be reading, this is not a Vylanous statement – IDM stands for Information Deficit Model.]  

What is it?

Let’s just go to Wikipedia

In studies of science communication, the information deficit model, also known as the deficit model or science literacy/knowledge deficit model, theorizes that scientific literacy can be improved with increased public engagement by the scientific community.[1] As a result, the public may then be able to make more decisions that are science-informed. The model implies that communication should focus on improving the transfer of information from experts to non-experts.

Currently, many studies challenge the information deficit model as it ignores the cognitive, social, and affective factors that influence one’s formation of attitude and judgements toward science and technology.

Once you see it, you see it everywhere. It’s the default model for education and, tragically, for most “activism”.

What are its consequences?

I am not going to defend the IDM (below I will explain why it persists).  Presumably the defence goes along the lines of “but people Need to Be Told The Truth (and the truth will set them free).

It pacifies and renders people passive.  It turns attendees at events into ego fodder.

It makes “sage on the stage” even more likely.

We get people being told that they must inform themselves  (and most of them then think that’s ALL they need to do.)

It individualises “action” as if what matters is changing people’s thoughts and that those changes of thought will a) persist and b) add up to something.

It means that there is less time/bandwidth for talking about what needs to be done differently.

If it is so bad, why does it persist?
 

Let’s start as charitably as possible.

  • It’s the default (“nobody ever got fired for buying IBM”) and so any innovation is treated with suspicion (see the Nick Machiavelli quote).
  • It’s how scientists are trained (another time I will rant about why we are STILL turning to natural scientists as guides for what needs to be done and how, and how that is completely fucking insane. But not today.)

Now, less charitably.

  • It sidelines questions of power (and the insane levels of inane consumption in the West), and most NGOs and academics etc are very keen not to talk about that.  NGOs need their nice middle class direct debiters, and they and academics need access to policymakers (politicians and bureaucrats) for their business model (lobbying and selling minor ‘successes’ as transformative) to work.
  • It means NGOs and campaigning groups can continue to provide ego-fodder to academics/star activists on speaking tours etc. Almost everyone (speaker, organisers, wilfully passive attendees) is happy, but movements don’t get built.
  • It allows those in charge to feel like they are the clever ones, the experts, bringing The Blinding Light of Enlightenment to the proles, the provincials, the great unwashed. It’s a cute little ancillary benefit.

What is to be done?

Ach, it’s too late to even slow the acceleration to our doom.  The time to slam on the brakes is before the bus goes off the cliff.  In 1988, when the climate problem became a political issue we were at 353ppm and were emitting about 20bn tonnes annually.  We’re now at almost 430ppm (and next year is going to see a 3ppm rise, at least) and are emitting 40bn tonnes.

Global CO2 emissions by year 1940-2025 | Statista 

Just as actions have consequences, so do inactions.  Our goose, like the planet, is well and truly cooked.

Still and all, if you want to die with dignity, if you want to push back against the IDM, well, I wrote a whole damn 60 page publication about it, Standard Public Meeting Syndrome and what to do about it. ” Nobody read it (why would you be that masochistic).

We will continue with IDM because it makes us feel good, because it is how we have always done things around here. That it absolutely will not upset the applecart is not just a bug, it is also, in some circumstances, a feature.

God, that pre-spawning vasectomy in 2004 was a good move.

Stuff for me to read at some point, if I can be bothered.

Herberz, M., Uenal, F., Gouiran, M. D., Krainz, M., Pagel, L., Schmid, D., … & Brosch, T. (2026). A systematic review and meta-analysis of communication strategies to promote climate action. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 103176. 

Knops, L., & Silberzahn, L. (2026). Beyond deliberation: Why we need affect for ecological democracy. Environmental Values, 09632719261472162. 

Jones, L., Lê, H., Parsons, K. J., Võ, T. T., & Halstead, F. (2026). From science to storytelling: Advancing a climate knowledge–action framework through reflections on youth‐focused, participatory action research in Vietnam. British Educational Research Journal, 52(1), 61-87. 

Suldovsky, B. 2017. The Information Deficit Model and Climate Change Communication | Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Climate Science | Oxford Academic 

Categories
Australia

November 7, 2012 – Terrible Australian Energy White Paper released

Fourteen years ago, on this day, November 7th, 2012,

2012 Energy White Paper released. Dreadful of course.

https://www.aip.com.au/sites/default/files/download-files/2017-09/Energy_%20White_Paper_2012-.pdf

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 395ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that Australian policy elites had been ripping shreds off each other in public on climate change since 2006. There had been an horrendous battle over a carbon price, and this had been a pyrrhic victory for Julia Gillard’s minority government. 

The specific context was that every few years there’s an energy white paper which purports to say the direction of travel for the federal government about what they want to see happen. Perhaps the most consequential of these was the 2004 white paper with its dreams of massive expansion of LNG, and so on this 2012 paper was regarded as tripe, and it’s hardly a surprise that there was little appetite for trying to integrate environmental thinking. At this point, the attitude will have been, “well, the greenies have got their ARENA and CEFC, what more do they want?”

What I think we can learn from this – we don’t have the governance structures. And we won’t. Oh well.

What happened next. This energy white paper, I think, sank without trace, like lots of the others. One wonders if these are really just busy work schemes to keep civil servants, relatively junior civil servants, feeling like they matter (not to be too cynical or anything). 

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 7, 1973 – Energy security avant la Ukraine: Nixon announces “Project Independence”

 November 7, 1997 – Australian governments bang heads in pre-Kyoto bash

November 7, 2000 – Australian “The Heat is on” report released

November 7, 2001 – Australian Conservation Foundation bluffs in support of Kyoto ratification

November 7, 2022 – journalist covering JSO protest arrested

Categories
Activism Obituaries

Blog Posts Not To Read: we’re toast b/c we’re stuck in information-deficit hell

Update 7/11/2026. There’s a sequel post – “Death to the IDM!”(*):  The Information Deficit Model, its attractions, consequences and persistence and ‘what is to be done’

The title of this blog post – which you shouldn’t read – is wrong. It should go “Blog Posts Not To Write” because

  • a) I’m repeating myself
  • b) It will change nothing
  • c) It will probably irritate well-meaning and hard-working people and what does it really matter if their efforts ‘fail’, because at a civilisational level, failure is (very) baked in.

But I spent a little time today with a journalist, recounting the long sordid history of the COPs, and it’s put me in an even-more-than-usual funk. Rather than process that, by, say – charging up and down the nearby slope with a weighted jacket and a backpack of bricks for 70 minutes – I am going to write an ill-advised rant. Can’t say I didn’t warn me, and you.


It’s this. The National Emergency Briefing is (as implied in the name) fatally wedded to an information deficit/scraped knee model of social ‘change.’ This is not a surprise, but there it is. My views are coloured by my general sense of nihilism, yes, but ALSO by the circumstances where I saw the 50 minute film – one of the worst (beyond comically bad) events I have ever attended, and that is saying something.

Yesterday I read this earnest and informative blog post by a university student doing an internship with the NEB people. It’s about a showing which was, predictably enough, attended by the grey hairs and the white hairs.

I would encourage you to read it. It’s got good stuff.

“That has probably been my biggest takeaway from working on the People’s Emergency Briefing. A film can open the door, but what happens around it matters too in terms of who is invited into the room, whether people have space to talk through what they have heard, and whether there is an obvious next step once they leave.”

But this is the problem. The ‘activation’ the NEB people are looking for is to put pressure on MPs so that the Prime Minister hosts a televised national emergency briefing. This, they think, will be the Batman slap that “everyone” needs.

But would such a broadcast be seen beyond those already switched on? Unless it was across all channels simultaneously “compulsory to watch”?

Why would it actually change the minds of the un-decideds/the uninformed? Why would a panel made up of various worthies (and even David Attenborough) ‘cut through’ to the vast numbers of people who don’t know much and don’t WANT to know much? And even if it did, then what? It’s not minds we need to change, but habits – and systems – of production and consumption. That’s a taller order. At absolute best, a “successful” NEB would lead to a few months of government/corporate pledges that were then forgotten/ignored. We’ve been here several times before. [“Extinction Rebellion says we quit: Why Radical Eco-activism has a short shelf life.”]

What is needed (but won’t happen, and can’t happen, and even if it could it is basically too late – we are in the Fafocene and are just going to have to suck it up) is for people in the ‘West’ with freedom of information/speech and assembly to (drumroll pls) form and maintain small groups that can federate and co-ordinate and resist co-optation, repression and exhaustion while bringing more and more people on-board and create civil society pressure and so force governments/states and corporations to behave radically in defence of the last shreds of ecological stability between us and abject breakdown and then, over time, reverse what damage can be reversed.

This is ridiculous to type. I am disgusted with myself for even bothering. It won’t happen, it can’t happen. And even if it could, we have had four decades of increasing emissions (20bn tonnes annually in 1988, up to 40bn tonnes now) and those emissions have thickened the blanket of heat-trapping gases in the atmosphere. All that heat is melting icesheets, changing weather patterns. The Jenga tower is no longer juddering as more blocks are taken out – it is starting to sway and next it will topple.

“We” were warned not to jump off the skyscraper. We decided to go ahead anyway and heck, someone will invent a parachute. We’ve passed a bunch of floors on the way to the pavement (or ‘sidewalk’ if you’re American) and as we pass each one, you can hear us saying “so far so good”. Or “we should hold a National Emergency Briefing”.

Coda from Yoda (“judge me by my sighs, do you?”)

If you’re reading this and you are thinking “why doesn’t this miserable a-hole shut his cakehole?” it’s an excellent question and I don’t have an answer, beyond “nobody put a gun to your head to read this and you were in fact warned.” If you’re following up that thought with “he never proposes anything positive of his own” you are absolutely wrong, but I don’t really have the energy to provide a list of links. This is a start though –

As to why nothing will change, I could go all “real subsumption of Civil Society by Capital” on yo ass. But instead, I invoke Cher, incentive structures and our inevitable doom.

And a bonus acronym – CARDIAC –

Categories
Australia

November 6, 1991 – met the new federalism, same as the old federalism

Thirty five years ago, on this day, November 6th, 1991,

A leading Australian conservationist has denounced the “new federalism” initiative as being “old federalism rejigged” and if implemented could jeopardise the future of proposed ecologically sustainable development policies.

Speaking at the National Press Club in Canberra yesterday, the executive director for the Australian Conservation Fund, Phillip Toyne, said that the initiative put forward by the Prime Minister, Bob Hawke, was not “a rethinking of our apportionment of power in government” but mere “rhetoric of change, not change itself”.

Iffland, K. 1991. Toyne: new federalism old federalism rejigged. Canberra Times, 7 November, p.3.

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 355ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that in 1988 the Australian public had been woken up to the threat of carbon dioxide build up, thanks in part to hard work by the CSIRO and various politicians. There had been an intense period of promises of policy making, etc. etc. including the Ecologically Sustainable Development (ESD) process. There had also been loose talk about holding a referendum, so that the federal government would have more power over states around greenhouse issues. This had come to nothing. The ESD, by this stage, was a dead letter, and everybody kind of knew it. Everyone was waiting for former treasurer Paul Keating to make his move to become Prime Minister, and Keating was infamously opposed to climate action.

What I think we can learn from this is that by late 1989 sorry, 1991 unless you were really sucking hard on the hopium pipe, you knew that there were serious problems ahead. 

What happened next Keating did, in fact, topple Hawke, and he did bin all of the ecologically sustainable development stuff. Australia announced an absolutely pitiful National Greenhouse Response Strategy, which they then ignored, and Australian emissions domestically climbed, and their coal exports climbed, and Australian prime ministers like Keating and Howard and Rudd do belong at The Hague, (it would be a relatively crowded dock).

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 6, 1961 – “Air Over Cities” pollution conference begins 

November 6, 1988 – Australian cartoonist nails response to #climate change

November 6, 1989 – Noordwijk conference – “alright, we will keep talking”

November 6, 1990 – Second World Climate Conference underway

November 6, 2001 – Howard plays the jobs-card vs Kyoto in Hunter Valley

November 6, 2009 – Kevin Rudd playing politics with the climate

November 6, 2011 – Keystone…

Categories
United Kingdom

November 6, 1958 – Gordon Manley on sea level rise would “make quite a mess of most of our sea ports”

Sixty eight years ago, on this day, November 6th, 1958,

By the year 2000 it may be possible to forecast good or bad summers many years ahead, an expert in climatology, Professor Gordon Manley, said in Coventry last night.

…

“There was no doubt that the ice in the polar regions was melting, resulting in an increase in sea level, he said… “If the sea level is rising to a much greater level than we think it would make quite a mess of most of our sea ports..”

Anon. 1958. Climate key explained in Coventry. Coventry Evening Telegraph, November 7, p.22

The amount of carbon dioxide in the air was 313ppm. As of 2026, when this post was published, it is 430ppm. This matters because the more carbon dioxide in the air, the more heat gets trapped. The more heat, the more extreme weather events. You can make it more complicated than that if you want, but really, it’s not. Fwiw, I have a tattoo of the Keeling Curve on my left forearm.

The broader context was that in 1938 Guy Callender had given a presentation at the Royal Meteorological Society about carbon dioxide build up and the heating of the planet. He received a lukewarm reception. However, one person who was on board was Gordon Manley, and Manley had been quoted in 1954 or ‘55 , as saying that in 30 years time we’d be growing grapes and have orange trees in the south of England.

The specific context was that it has basically been agreed by scientists studying within the International Geophysical Year, they’ve released an interim report in June that has said the world is one big greenhouse. And so here Manley is saying that seaports may be wiped out by rising sea level rise.

And it’s important to remember that whether you believed in carbon dioxide build up or not, there was enough evidence to convince everyone that the earth was warming up for whatever reason, and that ice would melt. . .

What I think we can learn from this is that the warnings were there.

What happened next – we kept emitting carbon dioxide in enormous quantities. The Fafocene is here.

On this topic, you might like these other posts on All Our Yesterdays

Xx

References

xx

You can see the chronological list of All Our Yesterdays “on this day” posts here.

What do you think? Does this pass the ‘so what?’ threshold? Have I got facts wrong? Interpretation wrong? Please do comment on this post, unless you are a denialist, obvs.

If you want to get involved, let me know.

If you want to invite me on your podcast, that would boost my ego and probably improve the currently pitiful hit-rate on this site (the two are not-unrelated).

Also on this day: 

November 6, 1961 – “Air Over Cities” pollution conference begins 

November 6, 1988 – Australian cartoonist nails response to #climate change

November 6, 1989 – Noordwijk conference – “alright, we will keep talking”

November 6, 1990 – Second World Climate Conference underway

November 6, 2001 – Howard plays the jobs-card vs Kyoto in Hunter Valley

November 6, 2009 – Kevin Rudd playing politics with the climate

November 6, 2011 – Keystone…

Categories
CO2 Newsletter CO2 Newsletter commentary

CO2 Newsletter Vol. 1, no. 4 – “The future is a flitting songbird; just because you see it clearly once doesn’t mean it’ll be in your line of sight forever.”

Professor Cyrus Mody (bio below) ponders the CO2 Newsletter, its place in history and how we think about the past, the present the future in a commentary on CO2 Newsletter, v. 3, n. 4 (May-June, 1982)

Professor Cyrus Mody

Other commentaries in this series have – rightly – marveled at William Barbat’s prescience in raising the alarm about climate change in the years around 1980. And the May-June, 1982 edition doesn’t disappoint in that respect. For example, an abstract by Karl W. Butzer on “Socio-economic implications … for CO2-induced climate change” concludes that “the pending crisis of the 21st century” [i.e., our present!] would take three forms:

  1. A substantial reduction of the world food supply, at a time of maximum demographic pressures upon global resources and shrinking energy reserves;
  2. Selective decline of productivity among the major economic and food-producing nations, implying a fundamental readjustment between developed and developing world regions; and
  3. Differential impacts within undersupplied nations of special complexity, as resources become inadequate to maintain controlled ecosystems, raising the probability of severe internal disruptions and confrontations within existing socioeconomic subsystems.

Some of those scenarios are still “pending” but the outlines of that forecast still ring eerily true.

Similarly, elsewhere Barbat quotes William C. Clark’s Carbon Dioxide Review: 1982. If the Lovinses soft path or the French nuclear path become universal, things will be okay; but, Clark says, “if, on the other hand, the world returns to high energy growth rates that characterized the third quarter of the present century, and fuels this growth with coal, then many of us now working on the CO2 question could see a 600 ppm world within our lifetime.” For the most part, the world did reject the Lovinses and nuclear power, and fossil fuel use did rebound, with coal remaining a dominant primary fuel across much of the world. The prediction of 600 ppm by, say, 2050 is a bit beyond the outer edge of IPCC predictions, but not by much (and the IPCC’s outer edge might well be an underestimate). So, once again, Barbat’s reporting was sound and if people had followed his lead the climatic drivers of today’s polycrisis would be much less pressing.

Yet we have to remember that the CO2 Newsletter is an historical source, and thus our admiration for Barbat should be spiced with source criticism. He wasn’t infallible, and the common ground with his admirers today was perhaps less than they might think. Other commentators have noted, for example, that his preferred form of climate action was “the French nuclear strategy” rather than “the Lovinses view of the global future;” as he put it in this issue, “the only non-fossil energy alternative presently feasible on a grand scale [is] nuclear fission.” Barbat’s contempt for what he called “the self-proclaimed environmental protection movement” also shines through here and in other editions of the newsletter.

Most notably – at least to an historian of science such as myself – in this edition Barbat reveals himself to be a continental drift skeptic. Now, continental drift and climate change do have a complicated relationship. For one thing, the influential historian of climate denialism, Naomi Oreskes, is also the world’s leading historian of continental drift; for her, both are examples of sciences where early investigators had good arguments and evidence but were ignored or overridden by conservative peers. Conversely, for climate denialists, obstructionists, and fellow travelers1 the lesson of continental drift is that supposed free-thinkers should be listened to, because they could turn out to be the next Alfred Wegener (or Darwin, Galileo, etc.).

Yet Barbat offers an unusual third option: that climate scientists should be listened to precisely because they have the hard facts – and the intuitive plausibility – that continental drift is missing!

The notion of actively drifting continents offers a contrasting study with the CO2-greenhouse theory in regard to disciplined scientific rigorousness and popularity. The greenhouse effect of atmospheric CO2 is solidly founded on thermodynamic investigations which have been checked and rechecked over and over again to produce a rather consistent range of appraisals (consensus)… In contrast, scientific disciplinarians are able to show that active continental drift is fatally flawed on both a physical and chemical basis. No proposed driving mechanisms can begin to match the forces that would be needed to move ponderous continental masses apart on highly viscous magma.

And yet, Barbat bemoans, “the notion of active drift was accorded credibility in virtually all school texts to produce popularity before a truly disciplined case was made, and large research enterprises have a vested interest in perpetuating the funding and publishing of one-sided studies” – i.e., much the same criticism that denialists make about climate science!

Thus, Barbat was something of a contrarian. It therefore wouldn’t have been surprising if he had later followed other contrarians – such as Freeman Dyson – in moving from climate awareness toward climate denial, especially given Barbat’s proximity to the oil industry, fondness for nuclear power, and antipathy toward environmentalists (all common traits of later eco-modernists and other hulpmollen). We have to evaluate his prescience circa 1980 as a product of its time from which we can’t infer his later evolution. The future is a flitting songbird; just because you see it clearly once doesn’t mean it’ll be in your line of sight forever.

What the CO2 Newsletter does tell us, though, is that climate awareness was the contrarian position circa 1980, at least for people in Barbat’s milieu. As he complained,

The CO2 problem suffers from a lack of popularity. No rock concerts have decried the CO2 buildup, and no bumper stickers advocating a halt to the CO2 buildup have appeared on fossil-fueled autos. Popular scientific magazines that advertise expensive non-utilitarian autos2 seem unusually silent on the CO2-greenhouse problem.

His aim for the newsletter, therefore, was “to fill the vacuum left by a noticeable de-emphasis of the entire CO2 problem in more widely read publications.” Notably, this edition of the newsletter opens with an open correspondence between Barbat and John Haun, president of the American Geological Institute and thus a staunch representative of the establishment. For Haun, Barbat’s “mental attitude [presents] a real danger in emphasizing all the bits and pieces of evidence that tend to support your hypothesis and denigrating or giving short shrift to the opposing evidence.” Barbat’s response is revealing: “To offset what may be overblown fears of ours, we have been directly urging editors of widely-read periodicals to give the CO2 problem more extensive coverage [and] more comprehensive studies on all aspects of the CO2 problem.”

And it’s on that score that I think we should give Barbat credit, rather than for his prescience alone. Much has been made in recent years of what various people and oil companies knew (or #Knew) about climate change circa 1980. But “knowing” is a fleeting act, not a permanent condition, especially for an organization like an oil firm. What’s important is what people and entities do at the moment that they know. Barbat knew – and he acted on that knowledge by spreading knowledge of climate change as widely as he could. And it’s thanks to lonely and courageous voices like his that denial became the rightly stigmatized position that it is today.

Footnotes

1 I propose the Dutch neologism hulpmol for someone who aids denialists but can’t be labeled one themselves. The word comes from the fanbase of the reality show Wie is de mol?, in which a “mole” sabotages their peers. A hulpmol is someone who wittingly or unwittingly assists the mole’s efforts and prevents their unmasking.

2 Elsewhere, it’s clear that he means fuel-efficient vehicles, which he says only encourage environmentalists to drive in ways that actually increase carbon emissions.

Bio

Cyrus Mody is Professor of the History of Science, Technology, and Innovation at Maastricht University and author of three monographs with MIT Press, most recently The Squares: US Physical and Engineering Scientists in the Long 1970s. He was PI of the Dutch Research Council-funded  Managing Scarcity project (VI.C.191.067), 2020-2026.